Garda Pay Ireland
Stage 2 competency deep dive

Using information and problem solving
facts first, then a decision you can justify

Gardaí arrive at situations where two people tell two different stories, information is missing and three things need doing at once. This area asks how you think when the picture is unclear.

Updated 21 November 2026 14 min read Sources checked 21 November 2026 Independent, not advice

The short answer

Using Information and Problem Solving is one of five Garda interview areas reported by prep providers, not named in the official booklets. It covers gathering facts before acting, weighing conflicting accounts, spotting what others miss, setting priorities and making a decision you can explain afterwards. It links to the Code of Ethics commitment to establish facts honestly and objectively and to the Information and Privacy standard.

Status of the name

Reported

prep providers only, not official

Closest Code standard

Honesty and Integrity

establishing facts objectively

Practice questions

30

in our bank for this area

Role plays tagged

12 of 20

in our practice pack

Contents +
  1. 1What the area is reported to cover
  2. 2Link to the values and Code of Ethics
  3. 3A simple problem-solving method
  4. 412 practice questions
  5. 5Prioritising: three things at once
  6. 6A full STAR model answer
  7. 7Strong vs weak evidence
  8. 8Facts, rumours and assumptions
  9. 9How it shows up in the role play
  10. 10Common mistakes
  11. 11How to practise
  12. 12FAQs
  13. 13Sources

What is this area reported to cover?

"Using Information and Problem Solving" is one of the five interview area names circulated by prep providers including starmethod.ie and GardaIP. No Garda Trainee booklet from 2024 to 2026 names the interview competencies, so this one is as reported by prep providers and not confirmed by publicjobs or An Garda Síochána.

Unverified name

Whatever label a board uses, working out what happened from incomplete and conflicting information is central to policing. If your Stage 2 briefing names different competencies, use its wording over ours.

The area seems to have two halves. "Using information" is about collecting, checking, recording and protecting facts. "Problem solving" is about turning those facts into a sensible decision, especially when time is short and the information is messy.

What the area probably covers (our reading, not an official definition)

Gathering facts before acting

What it looks like in a civilian example
You checked the order history before agreeing with an angry customer that it was lost

Weighing conflicting accounts

What it looks like in a civilian example
Two staff blamed each other, so you checked the logs and CCTV

Spotting what others missed

What it looks like in a civilian example
You noticed the same fault recurred every Monday after deliveries

Prioritising

What it looks like in a civilian example
You dealt with the safety issue first and the complaint second

Deciding without perfect information

What it looks like in a civilian example
You made a reasonable call with what you knew and reviewed it later

Explaining your reasoning

What it looks like in a civilian example
You could tell your manager exactly why you chose that option

Protecting information

What it looks like in a civilian example
You kept a colleague's personal details out of a group email

What is a simple method for problem solving answers?

Boards cannot see inside your head, so you have to narrate your thinking. A clear method makes your reasoning visible. You do not need to name it in the interview. Just let the steps show in your answer.

  1. 1

    Define the problem

    What exactly was wrong, for whom and how urgent was it? Many weak answers never say.

  2. 2

    Gather information

    Who did you ask, what did you check and what records or evidence did you look at?

  3. 3

    Check and weigh it

    Which sources agreed, which conflicted and what did you do about the gaps?

  4. 4

    Choose and act

    What options did you consider and why did you pick this one? Include safety and fairness.

  5. 5

    Review

    Did it work? What would you change? Did you pass on what you learned?

This maps neatly onto STAR: steps one and two are your situation and task, three and four are the action, five is the result. Put most of your time into steps two to four.

12 practice questions and what the board listens for

These twelve come from our original bank of 30 questions for this area: 24 past example questions, 5 what would you do questions and 1 values question. The middle column is a practice guide to what a competency board would typically listen for. It is not an official marking scheme.

Tell us about a time you solved a problem by gathering information before acting.
Past example · Professionalism, Accountability

What the board listens for
Finds out before deciding; Uses more than one source; Weighs the information; A clear link to the solution
A likely follow-up
What did you nearly miss?

Describe a time you had to make a decision without all the information you wanted.
Past example · Accountability, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Separates known from assumed; Manages risk; Decides in time; Reviews and adjusts
A likely follow-up
What would have changed your mind?

Tell us about a time you spotted something that other people had missed.
Past example · Professionalism, Accountability

What the board listens for
Observant; Acts on what they notice; Raises it tactfully; Real impact
A likely follow-up
Why did others miss it?

Give an example of when you had to weigh up conflicting accounts or information.
Past example · Respect, Honesty

What the board listens for
Hears each side; Looks for independent facts; Avoids early judgement; Explains the conclusion
A likely follow-up
Did you favour anyone?

Tell us about a time you had to explain something complicated in simple terms.
Past example · Respect, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Breaks it into steps; Plain words; Checks understanding; Patience
A likely follow-up
How did you know they understood?

Tell us about a time you had to prioritise competing demands on your time.
Past example · Professionalism, Accountability

What the board listens for
Clear reasons for priorities; Risk and harm first; Tells people affected; Revisits as things change
A likely follow-up
What did you put off?

Tell us about a time you checked a fact or a source before acting on it.
Past example · Honesty, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Healthy scepticism; Verifies before acting; Avoids rumour; Explains the impact
A likely follow-up
What made you doubt it?

You arrive at a minor road collision and the two drivers give completely different accounts. What would you do?
What would you do · Respect, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Safety and injuries first; Hears each separately; Looks for witnesses or cameras; Records accurately and stays neutral
A likely follow-up
What other information might exist?

An older man tells you he has transferred money after a phone call from someone claiming to be his bank. What would you want to find out?
What would you do · Empathy, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Reassures without blame; Gets key facts: when, how much, which numbers; Urgency about contacting the bank; Thinks about future protection
A likely follow-up
What would you say to stop him feeling foolish?

A rumour spreads on social media that a local man is responsible for a series of thefts. People start ringing the station. How would you approach this?
What would you do · Respect, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Treats it as unverified; Thinks about the man's safety; Records and passes information on; Does not share details
A likely follow-up
What would you say to callers?

You are on your own at the public office and three things happen at once: the phone rings, a person is waiting to report a stolen bike and someone comes in saying a child is lost in the shopping centre. What would you do first and why?
What would you do · Accountability, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Child safety first; Gets details quickly and gets help; Explains to others politely; Comes back to everyone
A likely follow-up
How would you keep the others informed?

A woman says her teenage daughter has not come home and is not answering her phone. What information would you want and why?
What would you do · Empathy, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Treats it seriously; Asks about risk factors; Gets a description and last sighting; Passes it on quickly and keeps the mother informed
A likely follow-up
What would make it more urgent?

Original Garda Pay practice questions. Not real Stage 2 questions.

The situational questions here, such as the collision with two different accounts or the older man who has sent money after a call from "his bank", are testing your questions more than your answers. List what you would want to find out and why each piece matters.

How do you prioritise when three things happen at once?

Our bank includes a classic: you are alone at the public office, the phone rings, someone is waiting to report a stolen bike and a person rushes in saying a child is lost in the shopping centre. There is no single perfect answer, but there is a clear principle.

1

Task
The lost child
Why
Possible risk to a vulnerable person; time matters. Get a description and last sighting, alert colleagues or a patrol straight away

2

Task
The phone
Why
It could be an emergency. Answer briefly, find out if it is urgent and take a number if not

3

Task
The stolen bike
Why
Important, but not urgent. Apologise, explain and ask them to wait or come back at a set time

Our model order for a practice question. Not an official procedure.

Risk to life first, then urgency, then everything else and tell people why they are waiting.

The board is also listening for communication. The person reporting the bike should not be ignored. A quick explanation keeps their trust. And on your own, the sensible move is to call for help early rather than juggling everything alone.

A full STAR model answer

Question: "Give an example of when you had to weigh up conflicting accounts or information." This is an original example from a fictional warehouse team leader. It shows the method above in a real-world setting. Your own example will be stronger because you can answer every probe.

  1. 1

    Situation

    about 15 seconds

    I am a team leader in a distribution warehouse. One evening a pallet fell from a forklift and narrowly missed a picker. Nobody was hurt, but the forklift driver said the picker had walked into the lane without looking and the picker said the driver had been reversing too fast.

  2. 2

    Task

    about 10 seconds

    I had to find out what really happened, make the area safe and report it fairly, without taking sides. Both were good workers and both were upset.

  3. 3

    Action: safety and separate accounts

    about 40 seconds

    First I stopped forklift traffic in that aisle and checked the picker was all right. Then I spoke to each of them separately in the office, so one account would not shape the other. I used open questions, such as "Talk me through the last minute before it fell" and wrote down what each said in their own words. I also spoke to a third worker who had been nearby.

  4. 4

    Action: checking the evidence

    about 40 seconds

    I did not want to decide on who seemed more convincing. I asked the shift manager to pull the CCTV for that aisle. It showed the picker stepped into the lane, but also that the pallet had been loaded unevenly and the driver had not used the horn at the blind corner. I checked the loading record and found the pallet came from a supplier with a history of poor stacking.

  5. 5

    Result

    about 20 seconds

    My report set out each account, what the CCTV showed and the loading issue, without blaming one person. The site added a stop line and mirror at that corner and returned the supplier's pallets for restacking. Both workers accepted the findings because they could see the evidence. I learned that conflicting accounts are often both partly true.

Why this answer works

  • Safety first, then information, which mirrors frontline priorities.
  • Separate accounts, open questions and notes in their own words.
  • The decision rests on evidence, not on who seemed more credible.
  • It finds a root cause nobody had mentioned.
  • The report is fair and objective, echoing the Code of Ethics.

For more complete models, see our example answers.

What is the difference between strong and weak evidence?

In this area, weak answers jump from problem to solution. Strong answers show the investigation in between.

"I worked out what the problem was and fixed it."

Strong evidence
"I checked the last three months of fault logs and saw it always failed after the Monday delivery."

"I believed her because she was more upset."

Strong evidence
"I took both accounts separately, then checked the till roll, which settled it."

"I made a decision quickly."

Strong evidence
"I had two options. The first was faster but risked the customer's data, so I chose the second."

"It worked out."

Strong evidence
"Faults dropped from weekly to none in the next two months."

No mention of the information used

Strong evidence
Named sources: records, people, systems, documents

Signals of a strong answer

  • ✓Questions you asked, in your words
  • ✓Sources you checked
  • ✓Options you weighed
  • ✓A reason you could defend

Signals of a weak answer

  • ✕Acting on the first account heard
  • ✕Assuming instead of checking
  • ✕A solution with no reasoning
  • ✕Ignoring the people affected

How do you handle facts, rumours and assumptions?

One situational question in our bank describes a social media rumour that a local man is responsible for a run of thefts, with people ringing the station. It tests whether you separate information from speculation and whether you protect people from unfair treatment.

What a strong answer to a rumour question includes

  • ✓ Recording any genuine information people give
  • ✓ Not confirming or spreading the rumour
  • ✓ Awareness of the man's safety and rights
  • ✓ Passing it to the right person or unit
  • ✓ Calm, factual messages to callers
  • ✓ Awareness that online claims can be wrong

The same discipline applies to your own examples. Show that you check before you act. Our bank's question about a time you "questioned an assumption that turned out to be wrong" is a good one to prepare, because it shows humility and rigour together.

How does this area show up in the role play?

The 2026 booklet confirms a role play at Stage 2 but its format is not published. Prep providers report a short brief, about 5 minutes to prepare and up to 5 minutes in role as a newly attested garda. That is not confirmed officially. In our practice scenarios, the character often holds a hidden fact that only good questions uncover.

Practice role plays that test this area

Parking and noise on a Galway estate

Setting
A housing estate in Knocknacarra, Galway, Saturday afternoon
Values tested
Respect, Professionalism, Honesty

The stolen passport on Grafton Street

Setting
Grafton Street area, Dublin city centre, Sunday afternoon
Values tested
Empathy, Professionalism, Respect

The phone call from 'the bank'

Setting
A farmhouse kitchen outside Ennis, County Clare, Monday morning
Values tested
Empathy, Respect, Professionalism

The messages from an ex

Setting
Station public office, a town in County Kildare, Friday evening
Values tested
Empathy, Respect, Accountability

The diesel thefts

Setting
A farmyard in County Roscommon, Wednesday morning
Values tested
Respect, Accountability, Empathy

The fender bender at the roundabout

Setting
A roundabout on the edge of Kilkenny city, Thursday at teatime
Values tested
Respect, Professionalism, Empathy

Abuse at the till

Setting
A convenience shop in Waterford city, Saturday evening
Values tested
Empathy, Respect, Accountability

The woman on the road at midnight

Setting
A road outside a village in County Wexford, a cold night in January, about midnight
Values tested
Empathy, Respect, Professionalism

From the Garda Pay Role Play Pack. Original practice scenarios, not real Stage 2 content.

Open questions such as "Is there anything else that's worrying you?" are how candidates find those hidden facts. Our role play scenarios page includes the phone call from "the bank", which turns on exactly this.

What are the most common mistakes in this area?

These patterns come up again and again in practice answers.

  • ✓ Skipping the investigation. Going from problem straight to fix.
  • ✓ Taking sides early. Believing the first or most confident account.
  • ✓ No sources. Never saying what you checked or who you asked.
  • ✓ Inventing procedure. In situational questions, claiming powers or processes you do not know.
  • ✓ Ignoring urgency. Dealing with paperwork before a safety risk.
  • ✓ Forgetting people. Solving the problem but leaving someone uninformed.
  • ✓ No review. Never checking whether the solution worked.
  • ✓ Careless with information. Sharing personal details more widely than needed.

See also Garda interview mistakes to avoid.

How should you practise this area?

Prepare two past examples: one where you found the real cause of a problem and one where you weighed conflicting information. Then practise situational questions out loud, listing what you would want to know before you decide.

Paid tool

Garda AI Interview Practice

Answer original problem solving and situational questions out loud and get feedback against the Garda values and Code of Ethics. €29.99 for 30 days or €44.99 for 90 days. The free question generator is a good first step.

Try AI interview practice →

Use the free interview question generator for daily practice. If you are still at Stage 1, the same skills help with the written exercise and verbal reasoning.

Get one problem solving scenario a week

An original what would you do scenario every week, with the questions a strong candidate would ask and a model order of priorities. Free.

Occasional emails, no spam, unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.

Frequently asked questions

What is Using Information and Problem Solving in the Garda interview?

It is one of five interview areas reported by prep providers and not named in the official booklets. It generally covers how you gather facts, weigh conflicting information, spot what others miss, set priorities and make a decision you can justify. It links to the Code of Ethics commitment to establish and report facts honestly and objectively and to the Information and Privacy standard.

What is a good problem solving example for a Garda interview?

A real problem where you found out what was actually going on before acting: a recurring fault, a stock or cash discrepancy, a complaint with two sides, a scheduling clash, a customer who could not explain what they needed. The board wants to hear the questions you asked, the sources you checked, the options you weighed and why you chose the one you did.

How do I answer the question about doing three things at once?

Put risk to life first. In our bank's version, a child lost in a shopping centre outranks a stolen bike report and a ringing phone. Say what you would do first and why, how you would keep the others informed, when you would call for help and how you would come back to each task. Reasoning matters more than a perfect order.

Do I need to know police procedures to answer these questions?

No. The board knows you are a trainee applicant. For situational questions, say what information you would want, who you would ask and what you would do while waiting. Saying you would check with a sergeant is a sensible answer, not a weak one. Inventing procedures or powers is the bigger risk.

How is this different from the Stage 1 tests?

Stage 1 includes verbal and numerical reasoning tests and a written exercise, which measure some of the same thinking under test conditions. At interview you show the same skills through behaviour: what you actually did with real information. Strong Stage 1 performers still need specific interview examples.

Can I use an example where I made the wrong decision?

Yes, if you can show sound reasoning based on what you knew at the time and what you learned when new information came in. Our bank includes a question about changing your plan because of new information. Boards respect candidates who adjust when the facts change rather than defending a first view.

Are these the real Garda interview questions?

No. Every question here is original Garda Pay practice material. We have no access to real Stage 2 questions and nothing here says a question will be asked.

Evidence

Sources and how we checked them

Every figure on this page comes from the sources below, read on 21 November 2026. Pay rates and rules change when new agreements are made, so check the source for the date you are reading this. Where we could not confirm something from an official source, the page says so instead of guessing. Spotted an error? Read our corrections policy.

  1. Garda Trainee 2026 Competition Information Booklet (campaign 4540): Stage 1 components and Stage 2 format; competencies not named
  2. Policing Authority: Code of Ethics for the Garda Síochána (2017): Honesty and Integrity (establishing facts), Information and Privacy, Police Powers, read 21 November 2026
  3. garda.ie: Our Policing Principles: The five Garda values
  4. Garda Trainee Applicant Vetting Policy (HQ Directive 068/2024): Lists the Code of Ethics principles
  5. publicjobs: Interview advice: How structured competency interviews work
  6. starmethod.ie: Garda Trainee interview: Commercial prep provider; source of the reported area name. Not official
  7. GardaIP: Garda Trainee Recruitment 2026: Commercial prep provider. Not official

Related guides

Becoming a garda

More in this series

See every becoming a garda guide →

Independent information, not advice. Garda Pay is not An Garda Síochána, publicjobs, the Policing Authority or a staff association. This guide explains published rules and rates. It does not consider your personal circumstances and is not financial, legal, tax or medical advice. Confirm anything you rely on with Garda HR, your association, Revenue or a qualified professional.