What is a job simulation question?
A job simulation question gives you a short scenario from the job and a set of possible responses. You may be asked to pick the best and worst, rank them or rate each one for effectiveness. Recruiters call this a situational judgement test.
The questions test judgement rather than knowledge. You are not expected to know Garda procedure yet. You are expected to recognise which responses are honest, fair, safe and professional.
The best answer is rarely the most dramatic one. It is usually the calm, lawful, respectful one that solves the problem.
What is confirmed about job simulation at Stage 1?
The 2026 booklet names an assessment questionnaire as one of four Stage 1 components. It does not describe the questionnaire. GardaIP and other prep providers describe it as including job simulation items. That is reported, not confirmed officially.
Assessment questionnaire is part of Stage 1
- Status
- Confirmed: 2026 booklet
It includes job simulation items
- Status
- Reported by prep providers
Response format (rate, rank, pick)
- Status
- Not published
Number of scenarios
- Status
- Not published
Scoring method
- Status
- Not published
| Detail | Status |
|---|---|
| Assessment questionnaire is part of Stage 1 | Confirmed: 2026 booklet |
| It includes job simulation items | Reported by prep providers |
| Response format (rate, rank, pick) | Not published |
| Number of scenarios | Not published |
| Scoring method | Not published |
Original scenarios only
Garda Pay is not the test provider and has no access to real questions. The scenarios on this page are written by us. Their ratings are our judgement, explained against the official Garda values and the Code of Ethics.
Why do police services use scenarios?
Much of a garda's job is judgement in situations nobody planned for. A scenario test is a cheap way to see, at scale, whether a candidate's instincts match what experienced officers think is right.
Tests
Judgement
not knowledge of procedure
Rewards
Balance
safety, fairness and honesty together
Penalises
Extremes
ignoring problems or overreacting
Scenario tests also reward consistency with the organisation's stated values. That is why the five Garda values and the Code of Ethics are the best revision material you have. Both are official and both are free.
The Garda values and the Code of Ethics as your marking scheme
An Garda Síochána sets out five values: Honesty, Accountability, Respect, Professionalism and Empathy. The Policing Authority's Code of Ethics sets out nine standards with written commitments. Together they tell you what an effective response looks like.
Honesty
- Related Code of Ethics standards
- Honesty and Integrity; Information and Privacy
- A strong response usually...
- Tells the truth, corrects errors, refuses favours
Accountability
- Related Code of Ethics standards
- Authority and Responsibility; Speaking Up and Reporting Wrongdoing
- A strong response usually...
- Owns the decision and escalates through the proper channel
Respect
- Related Code of Ethics standards
- Respect and Equality
- A strong response usually...
- Treats everyone with courtesy and without discrimination
Professionalism
- Related Code of Ethics standards
- Duty to Uphold the Law; Police Powers; Leadership
- A strong response usually...
- Stays calm, follows procedure, acts proportionately
Empathy
- Related Code of Ethics standards
- Respect and Equality
- A strong response usually...
- Recognises distress and vulnerability and responds to it
| Garda value | Related Code of Ethics standards | A strong response usually... |
|---|---|---|
| Honesty | Honesty and Integrity; Information and Privacy | Tells the truth, corrects errors, refuses favours |
| Accountability | Authority and Responsibility; Speaking Up and Reporting Wrongdoing | Owns the decision and escalates through the proper channel |
| Respect | Respect and Equality | Treats everyone with courtesy and without discrimination |
| Professionalism | Duty to Uphold the Law; Police Powers; Leadership | Stays calm, follows procedure, acts proportionately |
| Empathy | Respect and Equality | Recognises distress and vulnerability and responds to it |
Values from the June 2026 Garda press release; standards from the Code of Ethics. The mapping between them is our own.
Read the commitments under each standard at least once. Several of them read almost like the right answer to a scenario. For example, the Code commits gardaí to act with self-control even when provoked and never to ignore a colleague's unprofessional behaviour.
A five-step method for any scenario
Use the same steps every time. With practice they take seconds.
- 1
Safety first
Is anyone at risk right now? Any response that leaves someone in danger is weak, however polite.
- 2
Name the real issue
Is it integrity, a vulnerable person, a conflict, a mistake or a misuse of position? Most scenarios have one main issue.
- 3
Find the values at stake
Which of Honesty, Accountability, Respect, Professionalism or Empathy is being tested?
- 4
Check each option against the Code
Does it break a commitment, such as misusing information or ignoring wrongdoing? That option is likely the worst.
- 5
Prefer the balanced response
The best option usually solves the problem, treats everyone fairly and uses the right channel, without overreacting.
Signs of a strong option
- ✓Deals with the issue now, not later
- ✓Calm and courteous
- ✓Uses a supervisor or procedure when the issue is serious
- ✓Is honest even when that is uncomfortable
Signs of a weak option
- ✕Ignores a problem to avoid awkwardness
- ✕Bends a rule for a friend or colleague
- ✕Escalates aggressively or in public
- ✕Acts outside your role or procedure
How effectiveness ratings work
Many situational judgement tests ask you to rate each response on a four-point scale. We use the same scale in the worked scenarios below. The Garda test may use a different format, so check the official practice questions.
Most effective
- Meaning
- The best response available: solves the problem and reflects the values
Effective
- Meaning
- A reasonable response with a weakness
Ineffective
- Meaning
- Does not solve the problem, or creates a new one
Counterproductive
- Meaning
- Makes things worse or breaches the Code of Ethics
| Rating | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Most effective | The best response available: solves the problem and reflects the values |
| Effective | A reasonable response with a weakness |
| Ineffective | Does not solve the problem, or creates a new one |
| Counterproductive | Makes things worse or breaches the Code of Ethics |
If a test asks you to rank options, the same thinking applies. Put the most effective first and the counterproductive last, then decide the middle two by asking which leaves fewer problems behind.
Scenario 1: the free meal
Scenario
You are a probationer garda on patrol with an experienced colleague. You stop at a takeaway for your break. The owner waves away your colleague's money and says gardaí never pay here. Your colleague tells you to accept, because it is how things work locally.
A. Accept the free meal so you do not offend your colleague or the owner.
- Our rating
- Counterproductive
- Why
- Places you under an obligation to a local business, which the Honesty and Integrity standard warns against.
B. Pay for your own meal and say nothing to your colleague.
- Our rating
- Ineffective
- Why
- Protects you, but the Code commits you never to ignore a colleague's unprofessional behaviour.
C. Pay for your meal, then speak to your colleague privately and raise it with your sergeant if it continues.
- Our rating
- Most effective
- Why
- Acts with integrity, gives your colleague a chance to correct it and escalates through the right channel.
D. Pay and tell your colleague in front of the owner that you will be reporting them.
- Our rating
- Ineffective
- Why
- The aim is right but the manner is unprofessional and likely to inflame the situation.
| Response | Our rating | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A. Accept the free meal so you do not offend your colleague or the owner. | Counterproductive | Places you under an obligation to a local business, which the Honesty and Integrity standard warns against. |
| B. Pay for your own meal and say nothing to your colleague. | Ineffective | Protects you, but the Code commits you never to ignore a colleague's unprofessional behaviour. |
| C. Pay for your meal, then speak to your colleague privately and raise it with your sergeant if it continues. | Most effective | Acts with integrity, gives your colleague a chance to correct it and escalates through the right channel. |
| D. Pay and tell your colleague in front of the owner that you will be reporting them. | Ineffective | The aim is right but the manner is unprofessional and likely to inflame the situation. |
Values and standards at stake: Honesty; Accountability. Code of Ethics: Honesty and Integrity; Speaking Up and Reporting Wrongdoing.
Scenario 2: the queue at the public office
Scenario
You are on the public office desk. An elderly woman is very upset because her purse has been stolen. She is struggling to give details. A queue is building and a man near the back says loudly that he has been waiting twenty minutes.
A. Ask the woman to sit and come back when she is calmer, then serve the next person.
- Our rating
- Ineffective
- Why
- Clears the queue but leaves a vulnerable victim without help at the moment she needs it.
B. Reassure the woman, acknowledge the queue politely and ask a colleague to help with the other callers.
- Our rating
- Most effective
- Why
- Shows empathy to the victim, respect to the others and uses available support.
C. Tell the man he will have to wait like everyone else.
- Our rating
- Ineffective
- Why
- True, but curt. It risks escalating and does not address the delay.
D. Take the woman's details as fast as possible so you can move on.
- Our rating
- Effective
- Why
- Gets the report done, but rushing a distressed person may mean missing details.
| Response | Our rating | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A. Ask the woman to sit and come back when she is calmer, then serve the next person. | Ineffective | Clears the queue but leaves a vulnerable victim without help at the moment she needs it. |
| B. Reassure the woman, acknowledge the queue politely and ask a colleague to help with the other callers. | Most effective | Shows empathy to the victim, respect to the others and uses available support. |
| C. Tell the man he will have to wait like everyone else. | Ineffective | True, but curt. It risks escalating and does not address the delay. |
| D. Take the woman's details as fast as possible so you can move on. | Effective | Gets the report done, but rushing a distressed person may mean missing details. |
Values and standards at stake: Empathy; Respect; Professionalism. Code of Ethics: Respect and Equality.
Scenario 3: the mistake in your statement
Scenario
Two days after submitting a statement about an incident, you realise you recorded the wrong time for one event. Nobody else has noticed. Correcting it means admitting the error to your sergeant.
A. Leave it, because the error is small and nobody has noticed.
- Our rating
- Counterproductive
- Why
- An inaccurate record left uncorrected can mislead an investigation or a court.
B. Tell your sergeant straight away and follow the procedure for correcting it.
- Our rating
- Most effective
- Why
- Honest and accountable. The Code commits you never to hide or improperly interfere with information or evidence.
C. Quietly edit the original document yourself.
- Our rating
- Counterproductive
- Why
- Altering a record outside procedure is far more serious than the original mistake.
D. Mention it to a colleague and ask what they would do.
- Our rating
- Ineffective
- Why
- Advice is fine, but it delays the correction and passes the responsibility on.
| Response | Our rating | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A. Leave it, because the error is small and nobody has noticed. | Counterproductive | An inaccurate record left uncorrected can mislead an investigation or a court. |
| B. Tell your sergeant straight away and follow the procedure for correcting it. | Most effective | Honest and accountable. The Code commits you never to hide or improperly interfere with information or evidence. |
| C. Quietly edit the original document yourself. | Counterproductive | Altering a record outside procedure is far more serious than the original mistake. |
| D. Mention it to a colleague and ask what they would do. | Ineffective | Advice is fine, but it delays the correction and passes the responsibility on. |
Values and standards at stake: Honesty; Accountability. Code of Ethics: Honesty and Integrity; Information and Privacy.
Scenario 4: the favour for a neighbour
Scenario
A neighbour who knows you are now a garda asks you to look up who owns a car that keeps parking outside their house. They say it will save them a lot of hassle.
A. Do the check, because it is a minor matter and helps a neighbour.
- Our rating
- Counterproductive
- Why
- Using Garda systems for a personal favour breaches the Information and Privacy standard.
B. Refuse politely, explain you cannot use Garda systems for personal requests and suggest the proper route.
- Our rating
- Most effective
- Why
- Protects privacy, keeps the relationship and helps the neighbour to the right channel.
C. Refuse without explanation.
- Our rating
- Effective
- Why
- The right decision, but a short explanation would be more helpful and professional.
D. Say you will think about it, to avoid an awkward conversation.
- Our rating
- Ineffective
- Why
- Leaves the request open and the neighbour likely to ask again.
| Response | Our rating | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A. Do the check, because it is a minor matter and helps a neighbour. | Counterproductive | Using Garda systems for a personal favour breaches the Information and Privacy standard. |
| B. Refuse politely, explain you cannot use Garda systems for personal requests and suggest the proper route. | Most effective | Protects privacy, keeps the relationship and helps the neighbour to the right channel. |
| C. Refuse without explanation. | Effective | The right decision, but a short explanation would be more helpful and professional. |
| D. Say you will think about it, to avoid an awkward conversation. | Ineffective | Leaves the request open and the neighbour likely to ask again. |
Values and standards at stake: Professionalism; Honesty. Code of Ethics: Information and Privacy.
Scenario 5: filmed and insulted
Scenario
You and a colleague are dealing with a man who is being arrested on a busy street. A passer-by films you on their phone and shouts insults, calling you racist. The arrest is lawful and going calmly.
A. Tell the passer-by to stop filming and threaten to arrest them too.
- Our rating
- Counterproductive
- Why
- An emotional reaction that escalates the situation and may not be lawful.
B. Ignore the passer-by completely and focus on the arrest.
- Our rating
- Effective
- Why
- Keeps the focus on safety, but misses a chance to calm the crowd.
C. Stay calm, carry on with the arrest and, when safe, briefly explain to onlookers what is happening.
- Our rating
- Most effective
- Why
- Shows self-control when provoked and openness, both commitments in the Code.
D. Argue back that you are not racist.
- Our rating
- Ineffective
- Why
- Understandable, but it draws you into a dispute and away from the job in hand.
| Response | Our rating | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A. Tell the passer-by to stop filming and threaten to arrest them too. | Counterproductive | An emotional reaction that escalates the situation and may not be lawful. |
| B. Ignore the passer-by completely and focus on the arrest. | Effective | Keeps the focus on safety, but misses a chance to calm the crowd. |
| C. Stay calm, carry on with the arrest and, when safe, briefly explain to onlookers what is happening. | Most effective | Shows self-control when provoked and openness, both commitments in the Code. |
| D. Argue back that you are not racist. | Ineffective | Understandable, but it draws you into a dispute and away from the job in hand. |
Values and standards at stake: Professionalism; Respect. Code of Ethics: Authority and Responsibility; Police Powers; Transparency and Communication.
How to practise job simulation questions
After the five scenarios above, you should notice a pattern. The worst responses breach a commitment in the Code. The best are calm, honest and use the right channel. The middle options are usually right in aim but wrong in manner or timing.
- 1
Read the values and the Code
one eveningNote the commitments that sound most like scenario answers.
- 2
Work scenarios slowly at first
week 1For each response, write one line on which value it supports or breaks.
- 3
Speed up
week 2Do sets under time. Check where your ratings differ from the explanations and why.
- 4
Use the official practice questions
when the window opensCheck the real format and adjust your approach to it.
Before every answer, ask
- ✓ Is anyone at risk?
- ✓ Is this honest?
- ✓ Is this fair to everyone involved?
- ✓ Is this within my role and procedure?
- ✓ Does it ignore wrongdoing?
- ✓ Is it proportionate?
Garda Assessment Questionnaire Prep
A bank of original job simulation scenarios with ratings explained against the Garda values and the Code of Ethics, plus behavioural practice. 90 days' access, 14-day refund. Also in Stage 1 Complete (€49.99).
Or start free
Our free Stage 1 practice test includes original situational questions with explanations.
These skills carry straight into Stage 2. The role play is, in effect, a live job simulation. The integrity questions at interview often ask what you would do in situations very like these.
Get a new Garda scenario with worked ratings each week
When the next competition opens we will send one original job simulation scenario a week, with every response rated against the Garda values and the Code of Ethics.
Occasional emails, no spam, unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.
Frequently asked questions
What is the Garda job simulation test?
Job simulation refers to situational judgement questions: short scenarios set in policing with a choice of responses. Prep providers such as GardaIP report that these form part of the Stage 1 assessment questionnaire. The 2026 booklet names the assessment questionnaire but does not describe its content, so the job simulation element is reported, not confirmed officially.
How are situational judgement tests scored?
In most situational judgement tests, each response has an effectiveness rating agreed by experienced people in the role. You score more when your ratings or rankings are close to theirs. How the Garda questionnaire is scored is not published, so treat this as the general approach rather than a description of the real test.
What do Garda job simulation questions look for?
Good responses are typically lawful, honest, respectful and proportionate. They deal with immediate safety first, treat people with dignity, escalate through the right channels and do not ignore wrongdoing. The five Garda values and the nine standards of the Code of Ethics are the clearest official guide to what an effective response looks like.
Do I need to know Irish law for job simulation questions?
No detailed legal knowledge should be needed, because you have not yet been trained. Scenarios usually test judgement, ethics and how you treat people. Where an option involves stepping outside procedure or using powers for personal reasons, that is usually the weakest choice.
Is reporting a colleague always the right answer?
Not always in the first step, but never ignoring wrongdoing is a commitment in the Code of Ethics. The strongest responses often deal with a minor issue directly and professionally, then escalate to a supervisor if it continues. Serious misconduct, such as corruption or abuse of force, should be reported promptly.
Can I practise Garda job simulation questions free?
Yes. This page has five original worked scenarios and our free Stage 1 practice test includes more. The official practice questions arrive with the test link when the window opens. Our paid Assessment Questionnaire Prep at €24.99 adds a larger bank with explanations mapped to the values and the Code.
Evidence
Sources and how we checked them
Every figure on this page comes from the sources below, read on 21 November 2026. Pay rates and rules change when new agreements are made, so check the source for the date you are reading this. Where we could not confirm something from an official source, the page says so instead of guessing. Spotted an error? Read our corrections policy.
- Garda Trainee 2026 Competition Information Booklet (campaign 4540), publicjobs: assessment questionnaire named as a Stage 1 component (p.12)
- An Garda Síochána: over 4,100 applications (June 2026): the five Garda values
- Policing Authority: Code of Ethics for the Garda Síochána: the nine standards and their commitments, used to rate each scenario
- Garda Trainee Applicant Vetting Policy (August 2024): lists the Code of Ethics principles
- GardaIP: Garda Trainee Recruitment 2026: commercial provider; describes the assessment questionnaire with job simulation (not confirmed officially)
Related guides
Becoming a garda
More in this series
Independent information, not advice. Garda Pay is not An Garda Síochána, publicjobs, the Policing Authority or a staff association. This guide explains published rules and rates. It does not consider your personal circumstances and is not financial, legal, tax or medical advice. Confirm anything you rely on with Garda HR, your association, Revenue or a qualified professional.