Garda Pay Ireland
Stage 2 competency deep dive

Exercising authority
taking charge fairly, before you have a uniform

Gardaí make decisions people do not like and stand by them without losing their temper or their fairness. This area asks for proof that you can already do that in ordinary life.

Updated 21 November 2026 14 min read Sources checked 21 November 2026 Independent, not advice

The short answer

Exercising Authority is one of five Garda interview areas reported by prep providers, not named in the official booklets. It covers taking charge: making a call, saying no, enforcing a rule and challenging wrong behaviour while staying calm and fair. It links to the Code of Ethics standards on Authority and Responsibility and Police Powers and the values of Accountability and Professionalism.

Status of the name

Reported

prep providers only, not official

Closest Code standard

Authority and Responsibility

Code of Ethics, 2017

Practice questions

30

in our bank for this area

Role plays tagged

9 of 20

in our practice pack

Contents +
  1. 1What the area is reported to cover
  2. 2Link to the values and Code of Ethics
  3. 3Authority without a uniform
  4. 412 practice questions
  5. 5Firm, fair and proportionate
  6. 6A full STAR model answer
  7. 7Strong vs weak evidence
  8. 8Instructions you disagree with
  9. 9How it shows up in the role play
  10. 10Common mistakes
  11. 11How to practise
  12. 12FAQs
  13. 13Sources

What is this area reported to cover?

No official Garda Trainee booklet from 2024 to 2026 names the interview competencies. "Exercising Authority" is one of five names used by prep providers including starmethod.ie and GardaIP. It is not confirmed by publicjobs or An Garda Síochána, so this page treats it as as reported by prep providers.

The name is unverified

Whatever the board calls it, authority questions are a staple of every police interview because using power fairly is the core of the job. If your Stage 2 briefing names different competencies, follow its wording.

The area seems to cover more than being in charge. It is about using whatever authority you have in a way that is lawful, fair and proportionate and about having the courage to act when it would be easier to stay quiet.

What the area probably covers (our reading, not an official definition)

Making a clear decision

What it looks like in a civilian example
You closed a pitch because of lightning, even though the match was nearly over

Saying no with respect

What it looks like in a civilian example
You refused a refund outside policy, explained why and offered what you could do

Enforcing a standard fairly

What it looks like in a civilian example
You applied a dress code to a friend of the owner as well as everyone else

Challenging wrong behaviour

What it looks like in a civilian example
You told a colleague their joke about a customer was out of order

Taking charge in a crisis

What it looks like in a civilian example
You directed people at a car crash until the emergency services arrived

Staying calm when challenged

What it looks like in a civilian example
You kept your voice level when a parent squared up to you at the sideline

What counts as authority if you have never been a manager?

Almost everyone has exercised authority at some point. The board is interested in moments when you had to influence or direct someone who did not want to be directed and how you did it. Rank does not matter. Behaviour does.

Bar, door or hospitality

Authority situations that make strong evidence
Refusing to serve someone; asking a group to leave; applying an age check to a regular

Sport

Authority situations that make strong evidence
Refereeing a heated match; a coach enforcing a code of conduct with a parent

Lifeguard, steward or security

Authority situations that make strong evidence
Clearing a pool; moving a crowd; stopping a dangerous activity

Retail or office

Authority situations that make strong evidence
Enforcing a returns policy; telling a colleague a safety rule was not optional

Healthcare

Authority situations that make strong evidence
Enforcing visiting rules with an upset family; refusing a request that broke a protocol

Family or friends

Authority situations that make strong evidence
Stopping a friend from driving after drinking; challenging a sibling's behaviour

If you are early in your working life, see our guide to examples with no work experience. Former Defence Forces members and supervisors have plenty of material but should be careful to show fairness and explanation, not just command. Our guide for Defence Forces applicants covers that shift.

12 practice questions and what the board listens for

These twelve are drawn from our original bank of 30 questions for this area: 23 past example questions, 5 what would you do questions and 2 values questions. The middle column is a practice guide to what a competency board would typically listen for, not an official marking scheme.

Tell us about a time you had to tell someone that their behaviour was not acceptable.
Past example · Professionalism, Respect

What the board listens for
Addresses the behaviour, not the person; Clear and calm words; States what happens next; Follows through
A likely follow-up
How did they react?

Describe a time you had to apply a rule or policy that the other person disagreed with.
Past example · Accountability, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Applies the rule consistently; Explains the reason; Stays polite under pressure; Knows when to escalate
A likely follow-up
Did you agree with the rule?

Tell us about a time you took charge of a situation when nobody else would.
Past example · Accountability, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Steps forward without being asked; Puts safety first; Gives clear simple directions; Hands over appropriately
A likely follow-up
Why did nobody else act?

Give an example of when someone put you under pressure to change a decision and you stood your ground.
Past example · Honesty, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Decision based on reasons, not stubbornness; Calm under pressure; Open to new facts; Respectful throughout
A likely follow-up
Were you open to being wrong?

Tell us about a time you challenged a colleague or friend about something you believed was wrong.
Past example · Honesty, Accountability

What the board listens for
Recognises wrongdoing; Raises it directly and respectfully; Escalates when needed; Accepts personal cost
A likely follow-up
What if they had carried on?

Tell us about a time you calmed down a situation that was getting out of hand.
Past example · Professionalism, Respect, Empathy

What the board listens for
Reads the signs early; Lowers the temperature with voice and space; Listens to grievances; Keeps self and others safe
A likely follow-up
What did you do with your own body language?

How would you feel about enforcing a law you personally disagree with? Give an example of when you followed a rule you did not like.
Values · Professionalism, Honesty, Accountability

What the board listens for
Honest about personal views; Clear that the law is applied regardless; Discretion used fairly, not to suit themselves; A real example of following a rule they disliked
A likely follow-up
Where is the line for you?

You see a fellow probationer take a small item from a shop without paying while you are off duty together. What would you do?
What would you do · Honesty, Accountability

What the board listens for
Does not ignore it; Challenges in the moment; Understands the duty to report; Puts public trust above friendship
A likely follow-up
What if they are a close friend?

Tell us about a time you used your judgement rather than following the rule book exactly.
Past example · Accountability, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Discretion within the rules, not against them; Fair and explainable; Tells a supervisor or records it; Would accept being questioned on it
A likely follow-up
Who did you tell?

You are asked to move on a group of young people from outside a shop after a complaint. They say they are doing nothing wrong. How would you handle it?
What would you do · Respect, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Speaks to them with respect; Finds out the facts; Proportionate response; Explains their reasoning
A likely follow-up
What if they are right?

A driver you have stopped says they know a senior Garda and asks you to let them off. What would you say?
What would you do · Honesty, Professionalism

What the board listens for
Same treatment for everyone; Polite and clear; Not intimidated by the name; Records or reports the attempt
A likely follow-up
What if the senior Garda later rings you?

Your tutor Garda tells you to leave out a detail from your notebook because it would only cause paperwork. What would you do?
What would you do · Honesty, Accountability

What the board listens for
Keeps the record accurate; Raises it respectfully; Knows to escalate to a Sergeant if needed; Understands why records matter
A likely follow-up
What if they insist?

Original Garda Pay practice questions. Not real Stage 2 questions.

Several of these are hypothetical situations you could face in your first year: a colleague shoplifting, a driver dropping a senior garda's name, a tutor asking you to leave out a detail. You do not need to know procedure for any of them. You need to show that you would not let it go and that you would handle it with tact.

How do you show you are firm, fair and proportionate?

The best authority answers sit in a narrow band. Too soft and you look like you will not enforce anything. Too hard and you look like someone who will escalate every encounter. The Code's word "proportionate" is the target: as much authority as the situation needs and no more.

Firm is not loud. Use as much authority as the situation needs and no more.

Proportionate behaviour

  • ✓Explained the reason for the decision
  • ✓Gave the person a way to comply with dignity
  • ✓Kept the same rule for everyone
  • ✓Stayed calm when challenged
  • ✓Escalated only when lower steps failed

Out of proportion

  • ✕Pulled rank or threatened straight away
  • ✕Made an exception for a friend or a regular
  • ✕Argued back or matched someone's anger
  • ✕Ignored the problem to avoid conflict
  • ✕Humiliated the person in front of others

A useful sequence to describe: ask, explain, offer an option, then insist. Many real situations end at the first or second step. Show that you started low and stepped up only when you had to.

A full STAR model answer

Question: "Describe a time you had to apply a rule or policy that the other person disagreed with." This is an original example from a fictional candidate who supervises a hotel bar. It is here to show structure, not to be copied. Build yours from a real event you can be probed on.

  1. 1

    Situation

    about 15 seconds

    I supervise the bar in a hotel that hosts weddings. At one wedding last summer a guest who was clearly drunk, slurring and unsteady, came to the bar for another round. He was the groom's uncle and had been buying drinks for everyone all evening.

  2. 2

    Task

    about 10 seconds

    We are not allowed to serve someone who is drunk. It is the law and the hotel's policy. I had to refuse him without spoiling the wedding or causing a scene in front of a hundred guests.

  3. 3

    Action: refusing calmly

    about 40 seconds

    I asked my colleague to serve the queue and spoke to him at the end of the bar where it was quieter. I said, quietly, that I could not serve him any more alcohol tonight, that it was the law and that it applied to every guest. He got loud and said he had spent hundreds of euro. I kept my voice low and told him I understood and that I was not trying to embarrass him.

  4. 4

    Action: offering a way out

    about 40 seconds

    I offered him a soft drink and food from the kitchen and said I would happily serve his round of drinks to the others. He refused and tried to get a younger barman to serve him instead. I told the team clearly that the decision applied all night. Then I found his wife, explained calmly what had happened and asked her to help. I recorded the refusal in the incident book before the end of my shift.

  5. 5

    Result

    about 20 seconds

    His wife took him to sit down with some food and he went to bed an hour later. The next morning he apologised to me at breakfast. The duty manager used my incident note to brief the team on refusals. I learned that people accept a decision more easily if you give them a reason, keep it private and offer them something they can do.

Why this answer works

  • The rule was applied equally, even to a big-spending family member.
  • The candidate started low (quiet word, reason, alternative) before insisting.
  • Self-control under provocation is described, not claimed.
  • The team was briefed so the decision held all night: real authority.
  • A written record shows accountability, which the Code of Ethics values.

For more models, see our example answers and the STAR method guide.

What is the difference between strong and weak evidence?

Authority answers often fail because candidates describe a rule being enforced by someone else, or a situation where nobody pushed back. The board needs to see you holding a decision under some pressure.

"I told him to leave and he left."

Strong evidence
"He refused twice. I explained why, offered him a taxi and only then called security."

"My manager dealt with it."

Strong evidence
"I made the call myself and told my manager afterwards so she could back it up."

"I don't take any nonsense."

Strong evidence
"I kept my voice low and repeated the same reason each time he raised his."

"I let it go because he was a regular."

Strong evidence
"I applied the same rule I would to anyone, even though I knew him."

A story with no disagreement

Strong evidence
A story where someone challenged your decision and you held it fairly

No explanation of why

Strong evidence
A clear reason: safety, fairness, the law or a policy with a purpose

Before you use an authority example, check it shows

  • ✓ A decision that was yours to make
  • ✓ Someone who disagreed or pushed back
  • ✓ A reason you could explain to anyone
  • ✓ Calm, proportionate steps
  • ✓ The same standard for everyone
  • ✓ A result and what you learned

What if you are given an instruction you disagree with?

Several questions in our bank test the other side of authority: how you respond to it. As a trainee and probationer you will take a great many instructions. The Code of Ethics is precise here. Members commit to carry out lawful instructions to the best of their ability and to challenge instructions they believe are unlawful or against the Code. It adds that any decision not to follow an instruction "needs to be fully justified".

  1. 1

    Lawful but you dislike it

    Follow it properly. You can raise a concern afterwards through the right channel, but you do not refuse or half do it.

  2. 2

    Unsure whether it is right

    Ask a question to understand the reason. Often there is one you did not know.

  3. 3

    Clearly wrong or unlawful

    Do not comply. Say so respectfully, explain why and report it to a supervisor if it is serious. The tutor and notebook question in our bank is this case.

Boards like answers that show you can tell these three situations apart. A candidate who would obey anything is as worrying as one who would argue with everything.

How does this area show up in the role play?

The 2026 booklet confirms a role play at Stage 2, but its format is not published. Prep providers report a short brief, about 5 minutes to prepare and up to 5 minutes in role as a newly attested garda. That is not confirmed officially. Authority scenarios usually involve someone who does not want to do what you are asking.

Practice role plays that test this area

Parking and noise on a Galway estate

Setting
A housing estate in Knocknacarra, Galway, Saturday afternoon
Values tested
Respect, Professionalism, Honesty

The fifteen year old in the security office

Setting
Security office of a shopping centre in Cork city, Thursday after school
Values tested
Respect, Empathy, Professionalism

My son was stopped for nothing

Setting
Station public office hatch, a suburban Dublin station, Wednesday evening
Values tested
Respect, Accountability, Professionalism

Closing time at the pub

Setting
A pub in a small town in County Mayo, Saturday night after closing time
Values tested
Respect, Professionalism, Honesty

Who reported me?

Setting
Station public office hatch, a town in County Louth, Monday afternoon
Values tested
Honesty, Respect, Professionalism

The notebook entry

Setting
Station locker room, a Garda station in Limerick city, end of a night shift
Values tested
Honesty, Accountability, Professionalism

Abuse at the till

Setting
A convenience shop in Waterford city, Saturday evening
Values tested
Empathy, Respect, Accountability

Lost at the festival

Setting
Outside the gates of a music festival in County Laois, Saturday night
Values tested
Respect, Professionalism, Empathy

The thank you voucher

Setting
A restaurant in Killarney, County Kerry, Wednesday afternoon
Values tested
Honesty, Professionalism, Respect

From the Garda Pay Role Play Pack. Original practice scenarios, not real Stage 2 content.

In a role play, authority comes across in short clear sentences, a calm tone and an explanation of what will happen next. You can see two of these, including the pub at closing time and the notebook entry, on our role play scenarios page.

What are the most common mistakes in this area?

These mistakes come up repeatedly in practice answers for this area. Most of them make a candidate sound either soft or heavy-handed.

  • ✓ Telling a story about being tough. Boards are wary of candidates who enjoy conflict.
  • ✓ Choosing a story with no pushback. If nobody disagreed, you did not really exercise authority.
  • ✓ Hiding behind the manager. "I got my supervisor" can be right, but say what you did first.
  • ✓ Bending a rule for a friend. Even if it worked out, it clashes with fairness and impartiality.
  • ✓ Saying you would ignore a colleague's wrongdoing. Or that you would "have a word" and leave it there when it is serious.
  • ✓ Claiming powers. In hypothetical questions, saying you would arrest someone when you do not know if you could.
  • ✓ Losing the reason. Never explaining why the decision was right.
  • ✓ No learning. Ending the story without saying what you would do differently.

See also our full guide to Garda interview mistakes.

How should you practise this area?

Prepare two past examples and rehearse the hypothetical questions out loud. Authority answers are hard to judge on paper. Tone and pace matter, so record yourself and listen back for anything that sounds defensive or aggressive.

Paid tool

Garda AI Interview Practice

Answer original authority and integrity questions out loud and get feedback against the Garda values and Code of Ethics, with follow-up probes. €29.99 for 30 days or €44.99 for 90 days. The free question generator is a good place to start.

Try AI interview practice →

For free practice, use the interview question generator. If you want to turn your own experiences into structured answers, the Interview Answer Builder costs €24.99 for 90 days.

Get a weekly authority and integrity practice question

One original question a week with the follow-ups a board might use and what a strong answer shows. Free, until your Stage 2 date.

Occasional emails, no spam, unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.

Frequently asked questions

What does Exercising Authority mean in the Garda interview?

It is one of five areas reported by prep providers. The official booklets do not name it. It is generally understood to cover taking charge fairly: making a decision, saying no, enforcing a rule or standard and challenging wrong behaviour while keeping the other person's respect. It maps to the Code of Ethics standards on Authority and Responsibility, Police Powers and Duty to Uphold the Law.

I have never been a manager. Can I still answer authority questions?

Yes. Authority is not a job title. Stewarding an event, refereeing, lifeguarding, running a shift, coaching a team, refusing to serve someone at a bar or telling a friend they were out of order all count. The board wants to see that you can make a call and hold it calmly, not that you have managed staff.

Will I be asked about enforcing a law I disagree with?

It is a common theme in police interviews and the Garda self-assessment questionnaire mentions enforcing laws you may disagree with. Our bank includes it as a values question. A strong answer accepts that gardaí apply the law fairly whatever their personal views, then backs that up with a real example of following a rule you did not like.

Is it bad to say I backed down in an example?

Not if backing down was the right call and you can explain why. Exercising authority well includes knowing when new information should change your decision. What looks weak is giving in because someone shouted or because you wanted to be liked. Say what changed and why it was fair.

How do I answer the question about a colleague stealing?

Show that you would not ignore it. The Code of Ethics commits every member never to ignore a colleague's unethical or illegal behaviour. Say you would challenge it, give them the chance to put it right where that is safe and report it. Do not pretend it would be easy. Boards respect candidates who admit the loyalty pull but still do the right thing.

How aggressive should I sound?

Not at all. Firm is not loud. The strongest authority answers describe a calm voice, clear words, a reason for the decision and an offer of what the person can do next. Boards are listening for self-control, which the Code of Ethics asks for even when you are provoked.

Are these the real Garda interview questions?

No. Every question here is original Garda Pay practice material. We have no access to real Stage 2 content. The questions are designed to help you rehearse your own true examples against the behaviours a competency board is likely to look for.

Evidence

Sources and how we checked them

Every figure on this page comes from the sources below, read on 21 November 2026. Pay rates and rules change when new agreements are made, so check the source for the date you are reading this. Where we could not confirm something from an official source, the page says so instead of guessing. Spotted an error? Read our corrections policy.

  1. Garda Trainee 2026 Competition Information Booklet (campaign 4540): Stage 2 is an interview and role play on Zoom; competencies not named; self-assessment questionnaire
  2. Policing Authority: Code of Ethics for the Garda Síochána (2017): Authority and Responsibility, Police Powers and Speaking Up commitments, read 21 November 2026
  3. garda.ie: Our Policing Principles: The five Garda values
  4. Garda Trainee Applicant Vetting Policy (HQ Directive 068/2024): Lists the Code of Ethics principles
  5. publicjobs: Interview advice: How structured competency interviews work
  6. Intoxicating Liquor Act 2003, section 4: Offence for a licensee to supply alcohol to a drunken person; context for the model answer
  7. starmethod.ie: Garda Trainee interview: Commercial prep provider; source of the reported area name. Not official
  8. GardaIP: Garda Trainee Recruitment 2026: Commercial prep provider. Not official

Related guides

Becoming a garda

More in this series

See every becoming a garda guide →

Independent information, not advice. Garda Pay is not An Garda Síochána, publicjobs, the Policing Authority or a staff association. This guide explains published rules and rates. It does not consider your personal circumstances and is not financial, legal, tax or medical advice. Confirm anything you rely on with Garda HR, your association, Revenue or a qualified professional.