What are the ten mistakes that cost the most?
This is our ranking, based on how competency boards generally mark and what our practice questions are designed to draw out. The Garda marking scheme is not published, so treat it as informed advice, not a leaked rubric.
1
- Mistake
- Hypothetical answers to 'tell us about a time' questions
- Why it costs marks
- Nothing specific to mark
- Covered below
- Answering
2
- Mistake
- 'We' instead of 'I'
- Why it costs marks
- The board cannot tell what you did
- Covered below
- Answering
3
- Mistake
- Weak answers to integrity scenarios
- Why it costs marks
- Integrity is central to the job and the Code of Ethics
- Covered below
- Integrity traps
4
- Mistake
- One example stretched across many questions
- Why it costs marks
- Thin evidence for every area
- Covered below
- Preparation
5
- Mistake
- Examples that show poor judgement
- Why it costs marks
- The board marks the behaviour, not the outcome
- Covered below
- Examples
6
- Mistake
- Memorised scripts
- Why it costs marks
- Flat delivery, collapse under follow-ups
- Covered below
- Preparation
7
- Mistake
- Motivation clichés
- Why it costs marks
- Gives no evidence of real commitment
- Covered below
- Motivation
8
- Mistake
- Exaggerated or borrowed stories
- Why it costs marks
- Exposed by probing; risk at vetting
- Covered below
- Honesty
9
- Mistake
- No result or reflection
- Why it costs marks
- Half an answer
- Covered below
- Answering
10
- Mistake
- Untested Zoom set-up
- Why it costs marks
- Lost minutes and composure
- Covered below
- Zoom
| # | Mistake | Why it costs marks | Covered below |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hypothetical answers to 'tell us about a time' questions | Nothing specific to mark | Answering |
| 2 | 'We' instead of 'I' | The board cannot tell what you did | Answering |
| 3 | Weak answers to integrity scenarios | Integrity is central to the job and the Code of Ethics | Integrity traps |
| 4 | One example stretched across many questions | Thin evidence for every area | Preparation |
| 5 | Examples that show poor judgement | The board marks the behaviour, not the outcome | Examples |
| 6 | Memorised scripts | Flat delivery, collapse under follow-ups | Preparation |
| 7 | Motivation clichés | Gives no evidence of real commitment | Motivation |
| 8 | Exaggerated or borrowed stories | Exposed by probing; risk at vetting | Honesty |
| 9 | No result or reflection | Half an answer | Answering |
| 10 | Untested Zoom set-up | Lost minutes and composure | Zoom |
Most marks are lost to vague, borrowed or untested answers, not to a lack of experience.
Which preparation mistakes cause trouble later?
Many interview mistakes start weeks before the day. These are the habits that feel productive but leave you exposed.
Reading about interviews instead of practising
- What goes wrong
- You understand STAR but cannot do it under pressure
- Fix
- Say every answer out loud at least five times
Writing full scripts and learning them
- What goes wrong
- You sound rehearsed and go blank if interrupted
- Fix
- Learn bullet points: situation, task, three actions, result
Preparing three or four examples
- What goes wrong
- You reuse the same story for every area
- Fix
- Prepare eight to ten, covering every Garda value
Only practising alone
- What goes wrong
- Nobody asks you the awkward follow-ups
- Fix
- Get someone to probe each answer twice
Ignoring the role play
- What goes wrong
- It was added in 2026 and catches people cold
- Fix
- Practise at least three scenarios. See role play guide
Not reading your own interview form, if you submitted one
- What goes wrong
- The board asks about an example you have half forgotten
- Fix
- Re-read it the day before. The form itself is reported by prep providers, not confirmed officially
| Mistake | What goes wrong | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Reading about interviews instead of practising | You understand STAR but cannot do it under pressure | Say every answer out loud at least five times |
| Writing full scripts and learning them | You sound rehearsed and go blank if interrupted | Learn bullet points: situation, task, three actions, result |
| Preparing three or four examples | You reuse the same story for every area | Prepare eight to ten, covering every Garda value |
| Only practising alone | Nobody asks you the awkward follow-ups | Get someone to probe each answer twice |
| Ignoring the role play | It was added in 2026 and catches people cold | Practise at least three scenarios. See role play guide |
| Not reading your own interview form, if you submitted one | The board asks about an example you have half forgotten | Re-read it the day before. The form itself is reported by prep providers, not confirmed officially |
Build an evidence grid
List your eight to ten examples down the side and the five Garda values across the top. Tick which value each example shows. Any value without two ticks needs another example. Our competencies guide explains the grid in full.
Which examples should you avoid using?
A story can be true, recent and well told and still lose marks, because the behaviour it shows is not what a garda should do. Boards mark what you did, not whether it worked out.
Examples that tend to work
- ✓You followed a rule or procedure under pressure
- ✓You calmed a situation with words
- ✓You owned a mistake and fixed it
- ✓You raised a concern through the right channel
- ✓You helped someone vulnerable and passed it on to the right person
- ✓Recent: ideally in the last two or three years
Examples that tend to backfire
- ✕You bent the rules for a friend and nobody got hurt
- ✕You got physical to sort out a fight
- ✕You 'handled it yourself' rather than reporting it
- ✕You lost your temper but felt it was justified
- ✕You shared confidential information from work
- ✕Anything involving drugs, drink-driving or an offence
Be careful with examples involving your employer's confidential information. Describe the situation in general terms. Showing that you know what not to share is itself good evidence. If your experience is mostly outside work, see examples with no work experience.
Which integrity scenarios catch candidates out?
Integrity questions are where small slips do the most damage. The board is not looking for someone harsh. It is looking for someone who will not let things slide. The questions below are from our practice bank, not confirmed Garda questions.
You see a fellow probationer take a small item from a shop without paying while you are off duty together. What would you do?
- The trap
- Saying you would 'have a quiet word' and leave it there
- A stronger approach
- Challenge it, make sure the shop is not left at a loss and report it. Theft by a probationer is not a private matter.
A friend asks you to look up a neighbour's address on a Garda system once you have joined. What would you say?
- The trap
- Agreeing because it is 'only an address' or saying you would think about it
- A stronger approach
- Refuse clearly, explain that Garda systems are for policing purposes only and that misuse is a serious breach.
A business owner offers you a free meal every time you are on patrol near their restaurant as thanks for the work Gardaí do. How would you respond?
- The trap
- Accepting because refusing would seem rude
- A stronger approach
- Thank them warmly and decline. Gifts create an obligation, or the look of one.
Your tutor Garda tells you to leave out a detail from your notebook because it would only cause paperwork. What would you do?
- The trap
- Going along with it because the tutor is senior
- A stronger approach
- Record the detail. Raise it with the tutor first and, if pressed, with a supervisor.
A driver you have stopped says they know a senior Garda and asks you to let them off. What would you say?
- The trap
- Getting flustered or hinting it might help
- A stronger approach
- Deal with the driver exactly as you would anyone else and explain that calmly.
| Practice question | The trap | A stronger approach |
|---|---|---|
| You see a fellow probationer take a small item from a shop without paying while you are off duty together. What would you do? | Saying you would 'have a quiet word' and leave it there | Challenge it, make sure the shop is not left at a loss and report it. Theft by a probationer is not a private matter. |
| A friend asks you to look up a neighbour's address on a Garda system once you have joined. What would you say? | Agreeing because it is 'only an address' or saying you would think about it | Refuse clearly, explain that Garda systems are for policing purposes only and that misuse is a serious breach. |
| A business owner offers you a free meal every time you are on patrol near their restaurant as thanks for the work Gardaí do. How would you respond? | Accepting because refusing would seem rude | Thank them warmly and decline. Gifts create an obligation, or the look of one. |
| Your tutor Garda tells you to leave out a detail from your notebook because it would only cause paperwork. What would you do? | Going along with it because the tutor is senior | Record the detail. Raise it with the tutor first and, if pressed, with a supervisor. |
| A driver you have stopped says they know a senior Garda and asks you to let them off. What would you say? | Getting flustered or hinting it might help | Deal with the driver exactly as you would anyone else and explain that calmly. |
Questions are original Garda Pay practice material (ids gea12, gcn23, gea29, gea25, gea21). Approaches reflect the Code of Ethics standards on Honesty and Integrity, Information and Privacy and Speaking Up.
Proportionate, not robotic
A strong answer is not 'I would arrest them immediately'. It is honest, calm and proportionate: deal with it, do not hide it and use the proper channel. Our guide to Code of Ethics questions has a step-by-step method for these.
Which motivation answers fall flat?
"Why do you want to be a garda?" is where clichés cluster. None of these is wrong. Each just fails to tell the board anything about you.
I want to help people
- What the board hears
- The same as every other candidate
- Better
- Name who you have helped and how
No two days are the same
- What the board hears
- You want variety, not the job
- Better
- Say which parts of the work appeal and why
I have always wanted to
- What the board hears
- A feeling, not a reason
- Better
- Say what started it and what you have done since
It is a secure, well-paid job
- What the board hears
- The money is the main reason
- Better
- Mention security after the work itself, if at all
I watched a lot of crime shows
- What the board hears
- Unrealistic expectations
- Better
- Talk about real gardaí you have spoken to
| Cliché | What the board hears | Better |
|---|---|---|
| I want to help people | The same as every other candidate | Name who you have helped and how |
| No two days are the same | You want variety, not the job | Say which parts of the work appeal and why |
| I have always wanted to | A feeling, not a reason | Say what started it and what you have done since |
| It is a secure, well-paid job | The money is the main reason | Mention security after the work itself, if at all |
| I watched a lot of crime shows | Unrealistic expectations | Talk about real gardaí you have spoken to |
Our full guide to why you want to be a garda has a four-part structure and three example answers.
Which answering mistakes lose marks?
These happen in the moment. The fix for nearly all of them is the same: slow down, listen to the whole question and answer exactly what was asked. publicjobs puts it simply in its own advice: listen to the questions and give examples.
Hypothetical instead of past
- Example
- 'I would always listen to them...'
- Fix
- Start with when and where: 'Last summer at work...'
'We' instead of 'I'
- Example
- 'We calmed him down and we sorted it'
- Fix
- Say what you did. Credit others by name for their part
Answering a different question
- Example
- Asked about a mistake, describes a success
- Fix
- Repeat the key word of the question in your first sentence
All situation, no action
- Example
- Two minutes of background
- Fix
- One or two sentences of situation, then act
No result
- Example
- The story stops at what you did
- Fix
- Say what happened and what you learned
Too short
- Example
- Thirty seconds and silence
- Fix
- Aim for about two minutes per example
Arguing with a follow-up
- Example
- 'No, I think what I did was right'
- Fix
- Consider it honestly. 'Looking back, I could have...'
| Mistake | Example | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Hypothetical instead of past | 'I would always listen to them...' | Start with when and where: 'Last summer at work...' |
| 'We' instead of 'I' | 'We calmed him down and we sorted it' | Say what you did. Credit others by name for their part |
| Answering a different question | Asked about a mistake, describes a success | Repeat the key word of the question in your first sentence |
| All situation, no action | Two minutes of background | One or two sentences of situation, then act |
| No result | The story stops at what you did | Say what happened and what you learned |
| Too short | Thirty seconds and silence | Aim for about two minutes per example |
| Arguing with a follow-up | 'No, I think what I did was right' | Consider it honestly. 'Looking back, I could have...' |
For structure, see the STAR method. Taking two or three seconds to think before you start is normal and boards expect it.
Should you try to show legal or policing knowledge?
No. Candidates often worry they need to know the law, police powers or garda procedure. You are applying to be a trainee. Templemore teaches you the law. The board is likely to be assessing how you behave and think, not what you have memorised.
What helps
- ✓Knowing the basics of the training and the job
- ✓Knowing the five Garda values and what they mean in behaviour
- ✓Recognising an ethical issue when a scenario raises one
- ✓Saying you would seek advice from a supervisor where unsure
What tends to hurt
- ✕Quoting sections of Acts in answer to scenarios
- ✕Reciting the Code of Ethics standards by heart
- ✕Guessing at procedure and getting it wrong
- ✕Using police jargon from television
In the role play, which prep providers report casts you as a newly attested garda, the same applies. Calm, fair, honest behaviour matters more than knowing the right legal power.
Why is exaggerating or inventing an example so risky?
Boards probe. A borrowed or inflated example usually collapses under two or three follow-up questions: what exactly did you say, what did the other person do, what would you change? That alone costs marks.
The bigger risk comes later. The 2024 vetting policy for trainee applicants covers past employment and reference checks and the 2026 booklet warns that failure to disclose information can result in disqualification. An interview example that does not match what a former employer says is an avoidable problem.
Honesty is the first Garda value
Honesty is one of the five Garda values and Honesty and Integrity is one of the nine Code of Ethics standards. An answer that is exaggerated undermines the exact quality the board is testing. A modest true example always beats an impressive invented one.
Keep every example safe
- ✓ Only use things that happened to you
- ✓ Keep numbers and dates accurate or leave them out
- ✓ Say 'about' when you are not sure of a detail
- ✓ Credit other people for their part
- ✓ Do not upgrade your role: 'helped' is not 'led'
- ✓ Make sure it matches your application and interview form
Which Zoom mistakes are easy to avoid?
Stage 2 is held on Zoom (2026 booklet). Technical problems are rarely held against candidates, but a scramble in the first five minutes can knock your composure for the rest of the interview.
Using a work laptop with blocked software
- Fix
- Use your own device. The booklet warns that work and college networks can cause problems for online assessments
Not testing Zoom on the device you will use
- Fix
- Do a full test call two days before
Phone notifications and other tabs open
- Fix
- Do not disturb on; close everything except Zoom
Camera below eye level
- Fix
- Raise the device so the camera is at eye level
Looking at your own face
- Fix
- Hide self view once framed, or look at the camera
Panicking when the connection drops
- Fix
- Rejoin calmly. publicjobs says it is OK to tell the board there is a problem
| Mistake | Fix |
|---|---|
| Using a work laptop with blocked software | Use your own device. The booklet warns that work and college networks can cause problems for online assessments |
| Not testing Zoom on the device you will use | Do a full test call two days before |
| Phone notifications and other tabs open | Do not disturb on; close everything except Zoom |
| Camera below eye level | Raise the device so the camera is at eye level |
| Looking at your own face | Hide self view once framed, or look at the camera |
| Panicking when the connection drops | Rejoin calmly. publicjobs says it is OK to tell the board there is a problem |
Our Zoom interview tips cover set-up in full and what to wear covers clothes and lighting.
Which rules must you never break?
These are not about marks. Breaking them can end your application.
Do not record or share interview content
The 2026 booklet says candidates must not record or share test or interview content. Doing so can be an offence under section 55 of the Public Service Management (Recruitment and Appointments) Act 2004 and you may be disqualified. That includes posting questions on forums or social media after your interview.
- ✓ Do not record the interview or the role play
- ✓ Do not have anyone in the room helping you
- ✓ Do not post the questions you were asked online
- ✓ Follow the Stage 2 briefing rules on notes exactly
- ✓ Do not use another person's account or device details
- ✓ Tell the truth on every form, even if it seems minor
Which mistakes happen after the interview?
Candidates relax once the call ends. A few deadlines that follow are strict and missing them can cost your place.
- 1
Missing a message in the Application Centre
publicjobs uses the Review Communications area of your Application Centre. Emails can land in junk, so check both. The booklet suggests adding @publicjobs.tal.net to your safe senders.
- 2
Missing a form deadline
The booklet says forms must be returned within 7 calendar days or you will be deemed withdrawn.
- 3
Not asking for feedback
Feedback is available on written request. Ask whatever the result, so you know what to work on.
- 4
Leaving a review request too late
If you believe the process was unfair, a review under the CPSA code has a short deadline: our research of the booklet found 5 working days. Check yours. See how the interview is scored.
- 5
Letting your fitness slip
If you pass, the PCT comes next. See the PCT guide.
How can you catch your own mistakes before the board does?
You cannot spot most of these mistakes by reading your notes. You spot them by hearing yourself answer under mild pressure. Two or three full mock interviews over Zoom will catch more problems than a week of rereading.
Examples to prepare
8 to 10
covering every value
Times to say each aloud
5+
our guidance
Full mock interviews
2 to 3
on Zoom, with probing
Spot vague answers and missing results
AI Interview Practice listens to spoken answers and flags hypotheticals, 'we' answers and missing results. €29.99 for 30 days or €44.99 for 90 days. A friend with this page open is the free alternative.
Free help: the interview question generator and our bank of practice questions. The Garda Interview Pack (€14.99) has model answers showing what a mistake-free answer looks like.
Get the one-page mistakes checklist for the night before
One email with the twelve checks on this page as a printable list, plus an alert when the next competition opens.
Occasional emails, no spam, unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.
Frequently asked questions
What is the biggest mistake candidates make at the Garda interview?
In our view, giving general or hypothetical answers when the board has asked for a specific past example. Competency boards mark evidence of what you actually did. 'I would always treat people fairly' gives them nothing to mark. 'Last March I...' does. The marking scheme itself is not published.
Can one bad answer ruin the interview?
Not usually on its own, although nobody outside the process knows how marks are combined because the scheme is not published. What tends to hurt more is letting one bad answer rattle you for the next three. Finish it, take a breath and treat the next question as a fresh start.
Is it a mistake to admit I would find something difficult?
No. Admitting a difficulty and explaining how you would deal with it is a sign of self-awareness. Saying nothing would bother you, for example a sudden death or abuse from the public, is often less convincing than an honest answer.
Should I quote the Code of Ethics in my answers?
You do not need to quote it. Showing the behaviour it describes matters far more than naming it. One brief reference where it fits naturally is fine. Reciting the nine standards in answer to a competency question is a common mistake.
Is it a mistake to say I would report a colleague?
No. The Code of Ethics says everyone in An Garda Síochána must never ignore a colleague's unethical or illegal behaviour. Boards are likely to want to hear that you would challenge or report wrongdoing, in a proportionate way, through the proper channel.
What if I have made a mistake in my application or interview form?
Tell publicjobs as soon as you notice, using the competition contact in your Application Centre. Do not let the board find an inconsistency. Vetting includes past employment and reference checks and the booklet warns that failure to disclose information can result in disqualification.
Is it a mistake to bring notes to a Zoom interview?
Reading from notes is. Rules for notes are set in your Stage 2 briefing, so follow those. Even where a sheet is allowed, reading from it shows on camera and breaks your eye contact. Know your examples well enough that you only need a one-word prompt.
Evidence
Sources and how we checked them
Every figure on this page comes from the sources below, read on 21 November 2026. Pay rates and rules change when new agreements are made, so check the source for the date you are reading this. Where we could not confirm something from an official source, the page says so instead of guessing. Spotted an error? Read our corrections policy.
- Garda Trainee 2026 Competition Information Booklet (campaign 4540): Stage 2 format; communications via the Application Centre; 7-day form deadline; confidentiality of test and interview content
- Garda Trainee Applicant Vetting Policy (HQ Directive 068/2024): Past employment and reference checks; failure to disclose
- Policing Authority: Code of Ethics for the Garda Síochána: Honesty and Integrity; Speaking Up and Reporting Wrongdoing; Information and Privacy
- Public Service Management (Recruitment and Appointments) Act 2004, section 55: Section 55 makes a breach of the candidate obligations in section 54 an offence
- publicjobs: Interview advice: Listen to the questions; give examples; video interview set-up
- Garda Trainee Recruitment 2026 FAQ: Process and timings
Related guides
Becoming a garda
More in this series
Independent information, not advice. Garda Pay is not An Garda Síochána, publicjobs, the Policing Authority or a staff association. This guide explains published rules and rates. It does not consider your personal circumstances and is not financial, legal, tax or medical advice. Confirm anything you rely on with Garda HR, your association, Revenue or a qualified professional.