What is published about Stage 2 scoring?
Here is every published statement we could find about how Stage 2 leads to an outcome. It is a short list.
Stage 2 is a competency-based interview and role play on Zoom
- Source
- 2026 booklet; publicjobs page
- Status
- Verified
Those highest on the Stage 1 order of merit are invited first
- Source
- publicjobs page; 2026 FAQ
- Status
- Verified
Everyone who passes Stage 1 will be called during the competition
- Source
- 2026 FAQ
- Status
- Verified
Successful candidates are considered for appointment in order of merit based on interview scores
- Source
- 2024 booklet
- Status
- Verified for 2024
Candidates are passed to An Garda Síochána in batches
- Source
- 2026 booklet
- Status
- Verified
Feedback is available on written request
- Source
- 2026 booklet
- Status
- Verified
| Statement | Source | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Stage 2 is a competency-based interview and role play on Zoom | 2026 booklet; publicjobs page | Verified |
| Those highest on the Stage 1 order of merit are invited first | publicjobs page; 2026 FAQ | Verified |
| Everyone who passes Stage 1 will be called during the competition | 2026 FAQ | Verified |
| Successful candidates are considered for appointment in order of merit based on interview scores | 2024 booklet | Verified for 2024 |
| Candidates are passed to An Garda Síochána in batches | 2026 booklet | Verified |
| Feedback is available on written request | 2026 booklet | Verified |
publicjobs' general interview advice adds that interviews are structured, so that all candidates are assessed equally and that candidates are assessed on the competencies for the role. That is consistent with how Irish public service competency boards are normally run.
How does the order of merit work?
There are two rankings in the Garda Trainee process and they do different jobs.
- 1
Stage 1 order of merit
Everyone who passes Stage 1 is ranked by score. It decides when you are invited to Stage 2: highest first.
- 2
Stage 2 interview and role play
You are assessed by a board. The marking scheme is not published.
- 3
Order of merit for appointment
The 2024 booklet says successful candidates are considered for appointment in order of merit based on interview scores. This decides how soon you move to Stage 3.
- 4
Stage 3 and College intakes
Candidates go to An Garda Síochána in batches for the PCT, substance test, medical and vetting, then College places as intakes allow.
Stage 1 decides when you are interviewed. The interview decides how soon you could start.
One open question: the 2024 booklet's wording is the clearest statement we have and we have not seen it repeated word for word in 2026. The 2026 booklet confirms order of merit and batching, so the principle almost certainly still applies. Your Stage 2 briefing may say more.
What is not published?
These are the things candidates most want to know and nobody outside the process can tell them for certain.
Marking scheme and rating scale
- Status
- Not published
- What circulates online
- Various guesses from prep providers
Pass or qualifying mark
- Status
- Not published
- What circulates online
- Figures on forums, unverified
Competency names and indicators
- Status
- Not published
- What circulates online
- Five names reported by prep providers
Weighting of interview vs role play
- Status
- Not published
- What circulates online
- Nothing reliable
Whether Stage 1 scores carry into the final order
- Status
- Not published
- What circulates online
- Forum speculation
Board make-up
- Status
- Not published
- What circulates online
- Three-person panel, or chair plus nominee: accounts conflict
Interview length
- Status
- Not published
- What circulates online
- About 45 to 55 minutes (prep providers)
| Item | Status | What circulates online |
|---|---|---|
| Marking scheme and rating scale | Not published | Various guesses from prep providers |
| Pass or qualifying mark | Not published | Figures on forums, unverified |
| Competency names and indicators | Not published | Five names reported by prep providers |
| Weighting of interview vs role play | Not published | Nothing reliable |
| Whether Stage 1 scores carry into the final order | Not published | Forum speculation |
| Board make-up | Not published | Three-person panel, or chair plus nominee: accounts conflict |
| Interview length | Not published | About 45 to 55 minutes (prep providers) |
Be wary of precise claims
If a course tells you the exact pass mark or how many marks each competency is worth, ask which document it came from. Stage 2 briefings are confidential and sharing interview content can be an offence under section 55 of the Public Service Management (Recruitment and Appointments) Act 2004.
How do competency boards generally mark?
This section describes how competency-based interviews are generally run in Ireland and elsewhere. It is not the Garda scheme, which is not published. But it explains why the advice on this site works.
- 1
Each area has indicators
A competency or value is broken into observable behaviours, positive and negative. For example: listens before responding, explains decisions, takes ownership.
- 2
The board listens for evidence
Board members note what you actually did, in your words, against those indicators.
- 3
Each area gets a rating
Typically on a scale, often agreed between board members after the interview. Ratings reflect how strong and how relevant your evidence was.
- 4
Ratings combine into a score
The area ratings add up to an overall score, which sets your place in the order of merit.
Strong
- What the evidence usually looks like
- Specific, recent, clearly your actions, several positive indicators, good result and reflection
Good
- What the evidence usually looks like
- Specific and relevant, mostly your actions, some indicators shown
Acceptable
- What the evidence usually looks like
- Relevant but general in places, or actions partly unclear
Weak
- What the evidence usually looks like
- Vague, hypothetical, team-focused or off the point
No evidence
- What the evidence usually looks like
- No real example given, or the example shows the opposite behaviour
| Rating | What the evidence usually looks like |
|---|---|
| Strong | Specific, recent, clearly your actions, several positive indicators, good result and reflection |
| Good | Specific and relevant, mostly your actions, some indicators shown |
| Acceptable | Relevant but general in places, or actions partly unclear |
| Weak | Vague, hypothetical, team-focused or off the point |
| No evidence | No real example given, or the example shows the opposite behaviour |
Written by Garda Pay to illustrate common practice. The Garda Stage 2 scale, if any, is not published.
What generally earns and loses marks?
Competency boards tend to reward the same things wherever they sit. Mapped to the Garda values and Code of Ethics, here is what usually helps and what usually hurts.
Usually earns marks
- ✓One specific, recent example per question
- ✓Clear personal actions, in order
- ✓Reasons that show a value: fairness, honesty, safety
- ✓A result for the other person, not just for you
- ✓Honest reflection on what you would change
- ✓Answering the question actually asked
Usually loses marks
- ✕General claims ('I'm a people person')
- ✕Describing what the team did
- ✕Hypotheticals when a real example was asked for
- ✕Examples showing poor judgement you do not recognise
- ✕Blaming others for a setback
- ✕Long background with little action
The competencies guide lists the Garda values and Code of Ethics standards to show through your actions and the five areas reported by prep providers (not confirmed officially).
Why does saying 'I' matter for your score?
A board is marking you. If you say "we spoke to the customer, we checked the system, we sorted it", the board cannot tell which of those things you did. Evidence it cannot attribute to you is evidence it may not be able to mark.
We calmed him down.
- Personal and markable
- I moved him away from the queue and let him finish without interrupting.
We reported it.
- Personal and markable
- I went to the site manager, explained what I had seen and asked him to stop the work.
We fixed the process.
- Personal and markable
- I suggested a first-label check and my supervisor added it to the routine.
| Team-focused | Personal and markable |
|---|---|
| We calmed him down. | I moved him away from the queue and let him finish without interrupting. |
| We reported it. | I went to the site manager, explained what I had seen and asked him to stop the work. |
| We fixed the process. | I suggested a first-label check and my supervisor added it to the routine. |
You can still credit colleagues. "My colleague rang the ambulance while I kept him talking" is honest and markable. See the STAR method for more.
How do follow-up questions affect your score?
publicjobs says its boards probe the examples you give. Follow-ups are an opportunity, not a trap. They usually mean the board wants more evidence than you have given so far.
Use follow-ups to add marks
- ✓ Give the detail they ask for, briefly
- ✓ Add a reason for your action if you skipped it
- ✓ Name the result for the other person
- ✓ Offer an honest lesson if asked what you would change
- ✓ Stay with the same example unless asked for another
- ✓ Never invent detail to fill a gap
A borrowed or exaggerated example usually collapses under two or three follow-ups. That is why every answer should be true and one you remember well.
How might the role play be marked?
Nothing official says how the role play is scored or weighted. It was added in 2026. Prep providers report a short scenario as a newly attested garda, which is not confirmed officially.
What we can say is that a short live scenario can only show observable behaviour: listening, calm, respect, honesty, clear explanation and a sensible next step. If the role play is marked like most assessment exercises, the assessor will note what you did against a set of behaviours, not whether you knew the law.
Our working assumption
Prepare as if the role play carries real weight. There is no published evidence either way and the skills it tests are the core of the job. Our role play guide has a six-step structure and three practice scenarios.
Which scoring myths should you ignore?
There is a fixed pass mark of X%
- Reality
- No pass mark is published
The board has your Stage 1 score in front of it
- Reality
- Not published either way
Mentioning the Code of Ethics by name earns marks
- Reality
- Showing the behaviour matters more than naming it
Longer answers score higher
- Reality
- Specific answers score higher; long ones lose focus
Older candidates are marked down
- Reality
- No evidence. The age rule is set in the competition rules and the board marks evidence
Prep course X has the real questions
- Reality
- Sharing real content can be an offence; ask how they got it
| Myth | Reality |
|---|---|
| There is a fixed pass mark of X% | No pass mark is published |
| The board has your Stage 1 score in front of it | Not published either way |
| Mentioning the Code of Ethics by name earns marks | Showing the behaviour matters more than naming it |
| Longer answers score higher | Specific answers score higher; long ones lose focus |
| Older candidates are marked down | No evidence. The age rule is set in the competition rules and the board marks evidence |
| Prep course X has the real questions | Sharing real content can be an offence; ask how they got it |
Can you get feedback or ask for a review?
Yes, on both. The booklet says feedback is available on written request. If you believe a decision was unfair, the booklet sets out a review process under the Commission for Public Service Appointments code of practice. Our research of the booklet found a 5 working day deadline for a Section 7 review request, so act fast and check the exact deadline in your own booklet.
- 1
Ask for feedback in writing
Email publicjobs using the competition contact in your Application Centre and ask for feedback on your Stage 2 performance.
- 2
Read it against your answers
Note which areas were weaker. Compare with your evidence grid.
- 3
Decide whether to seek a review
Only if you believe the process itself was flawed, not because you disagree with the mark. Check the deadline in the booklet.
- 4
Prepare for next time
See reapplying. Rebuild the weak examples and practise with someone who will push back.
How can you maximise your score?
Without the marking scheme, the best strategy is the one that works for any competency board: specific, honest evidence, clearly structured, covering every area.
- ✓ Eight to ten real examples covering every value and area
- ✓ Each in STAR, about two minutes spoken
- ✓ At least one integrity example ready
- ✓ A clear, honest motivation answer
- ✓ Three or more role plays practised out loud
- ✓ Two full mock interviews on Zoom
Find your weak answers before the board does
AI Interview Practice gives feedback on structure and evidence in spoken mock interviews. €29.99 for 30 days or €44.99 for 90 days. Prefer free? Use the question generator and a friend.
Free help: the question generator, the question bank, our example answers and the Stage 2 hub. Paid extras: the Garda Interview Pack (€14.99), the Interview Answer Builder (€24.99) and the Role Play Pack (€24.99).
Tell me if the marking scheme is published
If publicjobs publishes how Stage 2 is marked, or the format changes, we will update this page and email you.
Occasional emails, no spam, unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.
Frequently asked questions
How is the Garda interview scored?
The marking scheme is not published. What is published: Stage 2 is a competency-based interview and role play and the 2024 booklet says successful candidates are considered for appointment in order of merit based on their interview scores. How marks are split, any pass mark and how the role play counts are not public.
What is the pass mark for the Garda interview?
None is published. publicjobs places successful candidates in order of merit. Any figure you see online for a Garda interview pass mark comes from a prep provider or forum and is not confirmed officially. You can ask publicjobs for feedback on your own result in writing.
Does my Stage 1 score count at interview?
Your Stage 1 score decides when you are invited to Stage 2, because invitations go out in order of merit. The 2024 booklet says the order for appointment is based on interview scores. Whether Stage 1 scores are combined with interview scores in 2026 is not published.
How are the interview and role play marks combined?
Not published. The role play was added in 2026 and no public document explains how it is weighted against the interview. Prepare as if both carry real weight, because there is no evidence either way.
Can I get feedback on my Garda interview?
Yes. The booklet says feedback is available on written request to publicjobs. If you believe the process was unfair, the booklet also sets out a review procedure under the Commission for Public Service Appointments code of practice, with short deadlines, so act quickly.
If I pass the interview, am I guaranteed a place?
No. Passing places you on an order of merit. You still have to pass the PCT, substance test, medical and vetting at Stage 3 and places are offered as College intakes allow. The 2026 FAQ puts the whole journey from application to College at 6-18 months (FAQ 2026); some outside this range; 4-6 weeks' notice of College place.
Evidence
Sources and how we checked them
Every figure on this page comes from the sources below, read on 21 November 2026. Pay rates and rules change when new agreements are made, so check the source for the date you are reading this. Where we could not confirm something from an official source, the page says so instead of guessing. Spotted an error? Read our corrections policy.
- Garda Trainee 2024 Candidate Information Booklet: Appointment considered in order of merit based on interview scores
- Garda Trainee 2026 Competition Information Booklet (campaign 4540): Stage 2 format; feedback on request; CPSA review procedure; batches to An Garda Síochána
- publicjobs: Garda Trainee 2026: Invitations to Stage 2 in order of merit from Stage 1
- publicjobs: Interview advice: Structured interviews; candidates assessed on the competencies; boards probe examples
- Garda Trainee Recruitment 2026 FAQ: All who pass Stage 1 are called during the competition; 6-18 months (FAQ 2026); some outside this range; 4-6 weeks' notice of College place to College
- Commission for Public Service Appointments: codes of practice: The framework for reviews of recruitment decisions
Related guides
Becoming a garda
More in this series
Independent information, not advice. Garda Pay is not An Garda Síochána, publicjobs, the Policing Authority or a staff association. This guide explains published rules and rates. It does not consider your personal circumstances and is not financial, legal, tax or medical advice. Confirm anything you rely on with Garda HR, your association, Revenue or a qualified professional.