The headline figures
The nearest like-for-like comparison with a garda is an Army private who has finished training: a Private 3 Star. Both are the main operational grade of their service, both are paid on public service scales and both got the same 1% general increase on 1 June 2026.
Start of the scale
- Garda
- €39,586
- Private 3 Star basic
- €34,090
- With MSA
- €42,890
Top of the scale
- Garda
- €60,936
- Private 3 Star basic
- €41,403
- With MSA
- €50,203
Years to the top
- Garda
- 8
- Private 3 Star basic
- about 6
Above the top
- Garda
- €63,129 then €65,595
- Private 3 Star basic
- none on this scale
| Garda | Private 3 Star basic | With MSA | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Start of the scale | €39,586 | €34,090 | €42,890 |
| Top of the scale | €60,936 | €41,403 | €50,203 |
| Years to the top | 8 | about 6 | |
| Above the top | €63,129 then €65,595 | none on this scale |
Garda: current table from 1 June 2026, calculated by us. Defence Forces: Department of Defence enlisted scales from 1 June 2026, published weekly; annual figures are weekly x 52.18, calculated by us. Private 3 Star scale for current entrants (effective from 12 July 2022 structure). Years to the top assume one point a year; the scale does not state the interval.
Garda vs private, basic, start
+€5,496
before MSA
Garda vs private with MSA, start
-€3,304
MSA included
Garda vs private with MSA, top
+€10,733
MSA included
On basic pay the garda is ahead at every point. Once MSA is included, the private is ahead for the first few years, then the Garda scale overtakes it as its bigger increments arrive.
Military Service Allowance: why it belongs in the comparison
Military Service Allowance is paid to every private, corporal and sergeant on top of basic pay, at €168.65 a week from 1 June 2026 (Department of Defence allowances, post-2013 enlisted). That is about €8,800 a year, calculated by us. It compensates for the conditions of military life, so it is paid whatever duties you do that week.
Gardaí have no equivalent flat allowance. Their extra pay comes from unsocial hours allowances for nights, Sundays and public holidays actually worked, plus overtime. So MSA is closer to part of basic pay than to the Garda extras, which is why we show the Defence Forces figures both with and without it.
Recruits in training
Recruits do not get MSA during recruit training. The enlisted scales show it from Private 2 Star and Private 3 Star. Since 12 July 2022, following the Commission on the Defence Forces, new privates get the full rate of MSA without first having to mark time on reduced pay.Year by year: who is ahead when
The Private 3 Star scale has 7 points. The Garda scale has 9 points to its maximum. The table lines them up by year on the scale.
Year 1
- Garda
- €39,586
- Private basic
- €34,090
- Private with MSA
- €42,890
- Garda vs private with MSA
- -€3,304
Year 2
- Garda
- €41,363
- Private basic
- €35,529
- Private with MSA
- €44,329
- Garda vs private with MSA
- -€2,966
Year 3
- Garda
- €44,672
- Private basic
- €36,856
- Private with MSA
- €45,656
- Garda vs private with MSA
- -€984
Year 4
- Garda
- €46,462
- Private basic
- €37,949
- Private with MSA
- €46,749
- Garda vs private with MSA
- -€287
Year 5
- Garda
- €49,093
- Private basic
- €38,788
- Private with MSA
- €47,588
- Garda vs private with MSA
- +€1,505
Year 6
- Garda
- €53,098
- Private basic
- €39,277
- Private with MSA
- €48,078
- Garda vs private with MSA
- +€5,020
Year 7
- Garda
- €55,859
- Private basic
- €41,403
- Private with MSA
- €50,203
- Garda vs private with MSA
- +€5,656
Year 8
- Garda
- €58,437
- Private basic
- €41,403 (top)
- Private with MSA
- €50,203
- Garda vs private with MSA
- +€8,234
Year 9
- Garda
- €60,936
- Private basic
- €41,403 (top)
- Private with MSA
- €50,203
- Garda vs private with MSA
- +€10,733
| Year | Garda | Private basic | Private with MSA | Garda vs private with MSA |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | €39,586 | €34,090 | €42,890 | -€3,304 |
| Year 2 | €41,363 | €35,529 | €44,329 | -€2,966 |
| Year 3 | €44,672 | €36,856 | €45,656 | -€984 |
| Year 4 | €46,462 | €37,949 | €46,749 | -€287 |
| Year 5 | €49,093 | €38,788 | €47,588 | +€1,505 |
| Year 6 | €53,098 | €39,277 | €48,078 | +€5,020 |
| Year 7 | €55,859 | €41,403 | €50,203 | +€5,656 |
| Year 8 | €58,437 | €41,403 (top) | €50,203 | +€8,234 |
| Year 9 | €60,936 | €41,403 (top) | €50,203 | +€10,733 |
Year n is point n on each scale. Both from 1 June 2026 rates. Private figures are weekly x 52.18, calculated by us.
The crossover comes in the middle years. From then on the garda's scale keeps climbing to €60,936 while the private's stops at €50,203 including MSA. A soldier who wants more must be promoted, while a garda gets a long-service increment of €63,129 later without promotion.
MSA puts a new private ahead of a new garda. The longer Garda scale reverses that within a few years.
A worked example: ten years in each service
Take two 22-year-olds. One attests as a garda, the other finishes training as a Private 3 Star. Neither is promoted, both move up one point a year and today's tables apply throughout. This is how their basic pay adds up over ten years on the scale, calculated by us.
Garda
- Total
- €510,442
- Average a year
- €51,044
Private 3 Star, basic only
- Total
- €388,101
- Average a year
- €38,810
Private 3 Star with MSA
- Total
- €476,102
- Average a year
- €47,610
| Total | Average a year | |
|---|---|---|
| Garda | €510,442 | €51,044 |
| Private 3 Star, basic only | €388,101 | €38,810 |
| Private 3 Star with MSA | €476,102 | €47,610 |
Garda current table; Defence Forces weekly rates from 1 June 2026 x 52.18. Future pay rises, overtime, duty allowances and promotion excluded.
Including MSA, the garda earns €34,340 more than the private over the decade. The garda first earns more than the private (with MSA) in year 5. Without MSA the garda is ahead by €122,341. The real-world gap is wider in the Garda's favour for anyone promoted, because Garda sergeant pay starts at €66,152.
The soldier has two advantages the example does not show. First, they were paid a salary through recruit training, while the garda spent 36 weeks on €354 a week. Second, they can draw a pension from 50, five years before the garda.
Overseas service
Defence Forces members on overseas missions receive overseas allowances on top of pay. The rates depend on the mission and are not in the scales we used, so we leave them out. Gardaí serving abroad on secondment also get an overseas allowance, which FOI figures reported by RTÉ put at a total of €633,000 for 30 members in 2025.Pay while you train
Here the Defence Forces is clearly better. An Army recruit is paid as a Private Grade 1 from day one: €555.13 a week, about €28,967 a year, calculated by us. Recruit training lasts 12 weeks and produces a 2 Star soldier, followed by 3 Star training (military.ie).
Army recruit
€555.13/wk
about €28,967 a year, no MSA
Private 2 Star
€633.54/wk
about €33,058 a year basic
Garda trainee
€354/wk
36 weeks; about €18,408 annualised
A Garda trainee gets a weekly allowance with accommodation and food provided while resident at Templemore, then moves onto point 1 at attestation. The Army recruit is on a salary sooner, but the Garda trainee is on the higher scale within a year. See the trainee allowance guide.
Promotion pay: corporal and sergeant
Promotion in the Army comes earlier than in An Garda Síochána, but the steps are smaller. Garda promotion to sergeant needs a competition and usually several years' service.
Corporal
- Basic, start to top
- €42,367 to €44,766
- With MSA
- €51,167 to €53,566
Army sergeant
- Basic, start to top
- €45,889 to €48,774
- With MSA
- €54,689 to €57,574
Garda (for comparison)
- Basic, start to top
- €39,586 to €65,595
- With MSA
- no MSA
Garda sergeant
- Basic, start to top
- €66,152 to €74,937
- With MSA
- no MSA
| Rank | Basic, start to top | With MSA |
|---|---|---|
| Corporal | €42,367 to €44,766 | €51,167 to €53,566 |
| Army sergeant | €45,889 to €48,774 | €54,689 to €57,574 |
| Garda (for comparison) | €39,586 to €65,595 | no MSA |
| Garda sergeant | €66,152 to €74,937 | no MSA |
Defence Forces weekly rates from 1 June 2026 x 52.18, calculated by us. Garda current table, calculated by us.
An Army sergeant's pay including MSA is close to what a garda earns in the later years of the Garda scale. A Garda sergeant is paid well above both. Read Garda sergeant pay for the full scale.
Cadets and officers
If you have a degree or a strong Leaving Certificate, the cadetship is the alternative to enlisting. Cadets start at €26,510 a year on appointment, rising through five cadet points (officers' Class A scales from 1 June 2026).
On commissioning, a Second Lieutenant earns €40,257 basic plus officers' MSA of €6,566, a total of €46,823. That is above the Garda point 1 of €39,586. The Garda has no direct-entry officer route: every garda starts as a trainee.
The Budget 2026 headline
The Department of Defence's Budget 2026 release in October 2025 quoted a Private 3 Star at €41,880. That figure includes MSA and uses the 1 August 2025 rates. The June 2026 equivalent is €42,890, calculated by us.Hours, rosters and leave
Neither service publishes a simple contracted week that we could verify. Since 20 January 2025 the Organisation of Working Time (Defence Forces) Regulations 2025 apply the 48-hour average week and rest rules to the Defence Forces, with exemptions for operations and certain training.
Gardaí on core units work 12-hour tours under the 2024 working time agreement, averaging about 42 hours a week before recovery days, calculated by us and illustrative only.
Annual leave
- Garda
- 29.5 days including public holidays (core roster)
- Defence Forces enlisted
- 28 days, plus 1 after 5 years and 1 after 12 years
On top
- Garda
- Public holidays are normal working days unless rostered off
- Defence Forces enlisted
- Defence Forces holidays and public holidays
Recruits
- Garda
- Not stated for Phase I
- Defence Forces enlisted
- 7 days
| Garda | Defence Forces enlisted | |
|---|---|---|
| Annual leave | 29.5 days including public holidays (core roster) | 28 days, plus 1 after 5 years and 1 after 12 years |
| On top | Public holidays are normal working days unless rostered off | Defence Forces holidays and public holidays |
| Recruits | Not stated for Phase I | 7 days |
Garda: garda.ie and the GRA working time agreement presentation. Defence Forces: military.ie careers FAQ.
Overseas service and exercises mean long periods away for soldiers. Gardaí work shifts at home but face rest-day cancellations at busy times. Our Garda roster guide explains the pattern.
Pensions and retirement
Both services are in the Single Public Service Pension Scheme on fast accrual for recruits who joined from 2013, under section 26 of the 2012 Act. The headline difference is the age you can draw your pension.
Scheme
- Garda
- Single Scheme, fast accrual
- Defence Forces
- Single Scheme, fast accrual
Minimum pension age
- Garda
- 55
- Defence Forces
- 50
Compulsory retirement
- Garda
- 62
- Defence Forces
- 62 (from 19 August 2024)
Member contribution
- Garda
- 3.3% of pay plus 4.2% of net pensionable pay
- Defence Forces
- 7.5% as quoted on military.ie
| Garda | Defence Forces | |
|---|---|---|
| Scheme | Single Scheme, fast accrual | Single Scheme, fast accrual |
| Minimum pension age | 55 | 50 |
| Compulsory retirement | 62 | 62 (from 19 August 2024) |
| Member contribution | 3.3% of pay plus 4.2% of net pensionable pay | 7.5% as quoted on military.ie |
Garda: our pension data from the 2012 Act and the Department of Justice. Defence Forces: military.ie rates of pay FAQ and the Department of Defence.
A soldier can draw an immediate pension from 50, five years earlier than a garda. For someone who joins young and wants a second career, that matters. Read the Single Scheme guide for how the Garda pension is worked out.
Life beyond the pay scale
Money is rarely what decides between the two. The working lives are very different. Some of the differences have a cost or a value that never shows up on a pay slip.
A soldier is based in a barracks or a naval base and can expect long exercises and, for many, overseas tours with United Nations or EU missions. A garda is allocated to a station after Templemore, can be posted anywhere in the State and works a shift roster at home. Our guide to where you will be stationed explains how first allocations work.
Often valued by soldiers
- ✓Overseas service and the allowances that come with it
- ✓Team life in a unit
- ✓Structured training and courses throughout a career
- ✓An earlier pension age
Often valued by gardaí
- ✕Living at home rather than away on exercise or deployment
- ✕A predictable roster pattern
- ✕Promotion competitions open to all ranks with the service
- ✕Overtime when it is available
Think about your family, where you want to live and what kind of work you want to be doing at 40. Then weigh the pay figures above against that. Our page on whether joining the Garda is worth it sets out the wider trade-offs.
Age limits, contracts and PRSI
The two services recruit very different age ranges. Garda trainees can apply from 18 up to the day before their 50th birthday at the closing date. Defence Forces recruits must be 18 to under 39 (military.ie).
Differences that are not on the pay scale
- ✓ The Army's initial contract is 5 years; there is no fixed term for gardaí
- ✓ Soldiers can be deployed overseas on peacekeeping missions
- ✓ Gardaí can be stationed anywhere in the State
- ✓ Defence Forces members pay PRSI under Class H, gardaí recruited since 1995 under Class A
- ✓ Discharge by purchase applies in the Army after recruit training
- ✓ Both services are covered by the same national pay agreements
Because the PRSI classes differ we do not compare take-home pay on this page. The Garda take-home calculator gives the Garda side.
Moving from the Defence Forces to An Garda Síochána
Soldiers who move across start as Garda trainees like everyone else. The pay effect depends on where you are on the Army scale when you go.
- 1
Check eligibility
before you applyAge, education and the other Garda Trainee rules apply in full.
- 2
Plan the drop in pay
Phase IFrom a private's pay with MSA to €354 a week for 36 weeks.
- 3
Attestation
the recoveryPoint 1 of the Garda scale, €39,586, then a point a year.
- 4
Ask about your pension
the Single SchemeBoth are in the same public service scheme; ask how your accrued benefits and fast accrual service carry over.
Our guide to joining from the Defence Forces covers the process and timing in detail.
The verdict
Pay is closer than many people think. Both services sit on public service scales, get the same general increases and share the same fast accrual pension scheme, so the comparison is unusually clean. The differences come from MSA, the length of each scale and the age you can draw your pension.
In short, with MSA a new private out-earns a new garda. The Garda scale is longer and steeper, so within a few years the garda is ahead and stays ahead, with long-service increments later.
In the Garda's favour
- ✓Higher pay from the middle years on
- ✓A top of €60,936 and long-service increments to €65,595
- ✓Overtime at time and a half and double time
- ✓Recruits accepted up to age 49
In the Defence Forces' favour
- ✕Paid a salary from the first day of training
- ✕MSA puts new privates ahead at the start
- ✕Pension from 50 rather than 55
- ✕Earlier promotion to corporal
Both scales move together under national pay deals. If the draft 2026-2029 agreement is ratified, its first step (200% or €1,200 from 1 September 2026) would take Garda point 1 to €40,786 and Private 3 Star point 1 basic to about €35,290, calculated by us. Ballot results are expected in the second week of December 2026.
Check you can apply to the Garda
Free eligibility checker: age, education, nationality and the other Garda Trainee rules in two minutes.
Garda Pay is independent and not connected with An Garda Síochána or the Defence Forces. This is general information, not financial advice.
Get told when Garda or Defence Forces pay changes
We email you when the 2026-2029 pay deal is decided, which moves both scales. We also tell you when the next Garda Trainee competition opens.
Occasional emails, no spam, unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.
Frequently asked questions
Who earns more, a garda or a soldier?
On basic pay a garda earns more: €39,586 at the start against €34,090 for a Private 3 Star on point 1. With the Military Service Allowance of €8,800 a year the private is on €42,890, which is ahead of a new garda. At the top, the garda's €60,936 is ahead of the private's €50,203 including MSA.
How much does a Private 3 Star earn in 2026?
From 1 June 2026, €653.32 to €793.46 a week basic plus MSA of €168.65 a week (Department of Defence). Annualised at 52.18 weeks that is €42,890 to €50,203 including MSA, calculated by us.
Is the Military Service Allowance pensionable?
A Dáil written answer in 2023 described the rates for junior ranks as including a pensionable Military Service Allowance. We read this in a search excerpt because the page itself was blocked, so check with your unit's pay office or PDFORRA.
Do recruits get paid during Defence Forces training?
Yes. A recruit (Private Grade 1) is paid €555.13 a week from 1 June 2026, about €28,967 a year, with no MSA. A Garda trainee gets an allowance of €354 a week for 36 weeks.
Can soldiers retire earlier than gardaí?
The Defence Forces minimum pension age in the Single Scheme is 50 (military.ie), against 55 for gardaí. Both now have a compulsory retirement age of 62, raised in 2024.
Can I join An Garda Síochána from the Defence Forces?
Yes. Serving members apply through the normal Garda Trainee competition and must meet the same eligibility rules. Our guide to joining from the Defence Forces covers timing, discharge and what happens to your pension.
Do soldiers get overtime like gardaí?
Gardaí are paid overtime at time and a half, double on Sundays and public holidays. Defence Forces pay works differently, with duty allowances for specific duties rather than general overtime. Compare the allowances that apply to the post you would hold.
Evidence
Sources and how we checked them
Every figure on this page comes from the sources below, read on 21 November 2026. Pay rates and rules change when new agreements are made, so check the source for the date you are reading this. Where we could not confirm something from an official source, the page says so instead of guessing. Spotted an error? Read our corrections policy.
- Department of Defence: Approved Enlisted Pay Scales with effect from 1 June 2026 (PDF): Private, Corporal and Sergeant weekly rates; the cover page still carries an older date, every table is headed 1 June 2026
- Department of Defence: Approved Allowances, post-2013 enlisted personnel, 1 June 2026 (PDF): Military Service Allowance €168.65 a week
- Department of Defence: Approved Officers Class A Pay Scales, 1 June 2026 (PDF): cadet and Second Lieutenant pay
- gov.ie: Department of Defence routinely published information, Defence Forces pay scales
- military.ie: Defence Forces rates of pay FAQ: Single Scheme fast accrual, minimum pension age 50
- military.ie: general careers FAQ: age limit, five-year contract, 28 days' leave, service to 62
- military.ie: Army recruit: 12 weeks of recruit training then 3 Star training
- gov.ie: Budget 2026 Defence press release (8 October 2025): Private 3 Star €41,880 at the time
- gov.ie: new mandatory retirement age for the Defence Forces (19 August 2024)
- S.I. No. 11 of 2025: Organisation of Working Time (Defence Forces) Regulations 2025
- Oireachtas: Dáil written answer on Defence Forces pay (20 June 2023): pensionable Military Service Allowance; read via a search excerpt
- garda.ie: Why Join An Garda Síochána 2026 (PDF): €39,194 at point 1 and €60,333 after 8 years, both as of 1 February 2026; €354 a week trainee allowance
- DPER Circular 22/2026: 1 June 2026 pay adjustment: 1%, the basis of our 1 June 2026 table
- income.ie: Garda pay scales: third-party reproduction of the garda.ie table, 1 February 2026
- Public Service Pensions (Single Scheme) Act 2012 (revised): fast accrual for gardaí; minimum pension age 55; contribution rates
- Department of Justice: Garda mandatory retirement age increased to 62 (3 September 2024)
- GRA: Midlands Working Time Agreement presentation (PDF): 12-hour core roster; 29.5 days' annual leave on the core roster
- Comptroller and Auditor General: Management of overtime in An Garda Síochána (2017, ch. 7): overtime at time and a half and double time; ranks paid overtime
- RTÉ: Gardaí paid over €225m in allowances on top of salaries (7 April 2026): 2025 allowance totals from FOI data
- gov.ie: Strengthening Public Services, Public Service Agreement 2026-2029 (PDF, dated 11 November 2026): the draft deal, section 3.1.2 pay increases
Related guides
Garda pay
More in this series
Independent information, not advice. Garda Pay is not An Garda Síochána, publicjobs, the Policing Authority or a staff association. This guide explains published rules and rates. It does not consider your personal circumstances and is not financial, legal, tax or medical advice. Confirm anything you rely on with Garda HR, your association, Revenue or a qualified professional.